Latest Headlines

BRRRR Deal Calculation: Purchase Price, Rehab, and Refinance Math

How to calculate a BRRRR deal from offer to cash-out refinance — the 70% rule, after-repair value estimation, rehab budgeting, refinancing at 75% LTV, and verifying you recover your full investment with worked examples

By Ebonie CaldwellReal Estate & Mortgage Strategist | Real Estate Investor & EducatorNovember 8, 202615 min read
BRRRR Strategy educational article illustration

BRRRR is a strategy that lives or dies by the math. Unlike a traditional buy-and-hold purchase, where a modest overpayment can be absorbed by long-term appreciation, a BRRRR deal depends on a precise sequence of calculations: the purchase price must be low enough, the rehab budget must be accurate enough, the after-repair value must be realistic enough, and the cash-out refinance must be large enough to return the invested capital. If any one of these numbers is wrong, the strategy fails — not in an obvious way, but in the slow, expensive way of capital trapped in a property that cannot be refinanced. The investors who succeed with BRRRR are not the ones who find the most deals; they are the ones who calculate the most accurately and walk away from deals that do not pencil out.

The good news is that the math is not complicated. Every BRRRR deal reduces to a small set of formulas: the 70% rule for maximum purchase price, the after-repair value based on comparable sales, the rehab budget based on itemized scope of work, the cash-out refinance based on LTV × appraised value, and the post-refinance cash flow and DSCR based on rental income and expenses. An investor who understands these five calculations can evaluate any BRRRR deal in minutes and know — before making an offer — whether the deal will recover their capital and produce a sustainable rental. An investor who does not understand them is gambling, not investing, and the house usually wins.

This article walks through every calculation in a BRRRR deal, step by step, with worked examples and real numbers. We start with the 70% rule and maximum purchase price, then move to ARV estimation, rehab budgeting, refinance proceeds, and the critical verification that the refinance returns the full investment. We include tables that show how each variable affects the outcome, callouts that highlight common errors, and a complete worked deal from offer to refinance. For the broader strategic context, see our BRRRR complete guide; for the ARV methodology in detail, see our after-repair value analysis article. By the end, you will be able to calculate any BRRRR deal with confidence — and, more importantly, you will know which deals to walk away from.

The Five Core BRRRR Calculations

Every BRRRR deal depends on five interconnected calculations. Understanding how they relate to each other — and how a change in one affects the others — is the foundation of accurate deal analysis. You cannot evaluate a BRRRR by looking at any single number in isolation; the strategy works only when all five calculations align to produce full capital recovery and positive post-refinance cash flow.

The five calculations are: (1) After-Repair Value (ARV) — the property's estimated value after renovation, based on comparable sales. (2) Maximum Purchase Price — derived from the 70% rule, which ensures you buy at a deep enough discount. (3) Rehab Budget — the itemized cost of renovations, including contingency. (4) Cash-Out Refinance Proceeds — the loan amount available at the lender's LTV × appraised value. (5) Post-Refinance Cash Flow and DSCR — the rental income and expenses that determine whether the refinanced property is sustainable. Each of these is explored in detail in the sections that follow.

CalculationFormulaPurpose
After-Repair Value (ARV)Comparable sales analysisEstimate post-rehab property value
Max Purchase Price(ARV × 0.70) − Rehab CostEnsure deep enough discount for BRRRR
Rehab BudgetItemized scope of work + 10–20% contingencyAccurately estimate renovation cost
Refinance ProceedsAppraised Value × LTV (70–80%)Determine capital recovered at refinance
Post-Refi Cash Flow & DSCRNOI ÷ Annual Debt ServiceVerify property is sustainable long-term

The five calculations are interdependent. A higher ARV allows a higher purchase price and larger refinance, but an inflated ARV risks an appraisal shortfall. A lower rehab budget improves the deal math, but an underestimated rehab leads to overruns that trap capital. Change one variable and you must re-evaluate the entire deal.

Step 1: Estimating After-Repair Value (ARV)

After-Repair Value is the single most important number in a BRRRR deal, because every other calculation — purchase price, refinance proceeds, capital recovery — derives from it. ARV is the estimated market value of the property after all renovations are complete, expressed as the price a willing buyer would pay in the current market. It is not what you hope the property is worth; it is what comparable properties have actually sold for, adjusted for differences. Estimating ARV accurately is the skill that separates successful BRRRR investors from those who consistently lose money.

ARV is estimated using comparable sales analysis — the same method a professional appraiser uses. The process is: identify 3 to 5 properties that have sold in the last 6 to 12 months, within 0.5 to 1 mile of the subject property, with similar characteristics (same bedroom/bathroom count, similar square footage within 15 percent, same property type and age, similar lot size). These are your comparables. For each comparable, note the sale price, the date of sale, and the differences from your subject property (condition, size, features, location). Adjust each comparable's sale price up or down to account for these differences, then average the adjusted values to arrive at your ARV estimate.

For a BRRRR specifically, the ARV must reflect the property in its renovated condition — not its current distressed condition. This means your comparables should be properties that are in turnkey or rental-ready condition, not other distressed properties. If all the recent sales in the area are distressed fixer-uppers, you may need to look at sales from a wider timeframe (up to 12 months) or a slightly wider radius to find renovated comparables. Be conservative: if your analysis suggests an ARV range of $200,000 to $215,000, use $200,000 or $205,000 in your deal math, not $215,000. The appraisal will come in at a single number, and you want to be pleasantly surprised, not devastated. For a detailed methodology on ARV estimation and adjustment, see our after-repair value analysis article.

Let us work through an ARV estimate for a hypothetical 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom, 1,400-square-foot single-family home in a mid-market neighborhood. We find four comparable sales in the last 9 months within 0.5 miles: Comp A (3BR/2BA, 1,350 sqft, renovated, sold for $208,000), Comp B (3BR/2BA, 1,450 sqft, renovated, sold for $215,000), Comp C (3BR/2BA, 1,400 sqft, partially updated, sold for $198,000), and Comp D (3BR/1.5BA, 1,380 sqft, renovated, sold for $195,000). Comp A is slightly smaller (+$1,500 adjustment for 50 sqft difference). Comp B is slightly larger (−$2,000 adjustment). Comp C is partially updated, not fully renovated (−$5,000 adjustment for condition). Comp D has only 1.5 baths, not 2 (−$5,000 adjustment for bathroom). Adjusted values: $209,500, $213,000, $193,000, $190,000. Average: $201,375. We round conservatively to $200,000 as our ARV estimate.

Warning: The most common ARV error is cherry-picking the highest comparable and ignoring the rest. An appraiser will use all relevant comparables and adjust for differences — if your ARV is based on the best sale while ignoring three lower sales, your appraisal will come in below your estimate and your refinance will fall short. Use all comparable sales and adjust honestly. Conservative ARV estimation is the single best protection against BRRRR failure.

Step 2: The 70% Rule and Maximum Purchase Price

Once you have an ARV estimate and a preliminary rehab budget, you can calculate the maximum purchase price using the 70% rule. The formula is: Maximum Purchase Price = (ARV × 0.70) − Rehab Cost. The 70% factor accounts for the combined costs of the rehab, closing costs, holding costs, and the equity margin needed for the cash-out refinance to return your full investment. The rule ensures that your total investment (purchase + rehab) does not exceed 70% of ARV, leaving a 30% margin that the refinance — typically at 75-80% LTV — will extract as returned capital.

The 70% rule works because of the gap between the total investment and the refinance LTV. If your total investment is 70% of ARV and you refinance at 75% of ARV, the loan proceeds exceed your investment by 5% of ARV — meaning you recover 100% of your capital plus a surplus. If your total investment is 75% of ARV and you refinance at 75%, you recover nothing. If your total investment is 80% of ARV and you refinance at 75%, you leave 5% of ARV permanently trapped. The 70% rule is specifically designed to ensure the refinance returns your capital with a margin of safety for appraisal shortfalls and cost overruns.

Let us apply the formula to our hypothetical deal. With an ARV of $200,000 and an estimated rehab cost of $30,000: Maximum Purchase Price = ($200,000 × 0.70) − $30,000 = $140,000 − $30,000 = $110,000. If you can buy the property for $110,000, your total investment is $140,000 (70% of ARV), and a refinance at 75% LTV ($150,000) returns your full investment plus a $10,000 surplus. If the seller wants $125,000, your total investment becomes $155,000 (77.5% of ARV), and a 75% refinance ($150,000) leaves $5,000 trapped — the deal does not meet the 70% rule and should be passed or renegotiated.

The table below shows how the maximum purchase price changes with different ARV and rehab combinations. Notice that a $10,000 increase in rehab cost reduces the maximum purchase price by $10,000 — the two are directly linked. Similarly, a $10,000 increase in ARV increases the maximum purchase price by $7,000 (because the 70% factor applies to ARV). Understanding these relationships helps you evaluate deals quickly: if a seller's price is above your maximum, you know exactly how much the ARV would need to increase or the rehab would need to decrease to make the deal work.

ARVRehab Cost70% of ARVMax Purchase PriceTotal Investment
$200,000$30,000$140,000$110,000$140,000 (70.0% of ARV)
$210,000$35,000$147,000$112,000$147,000 (70.0% of ARV)
$180,000$25,000$126,000$101,000$126,000 (70.0% of ARV)
$200,000$40,000$140,000$100,000$140,000 (70.0% of ARV)
$250,000$50,000$175,000$125,000$175,000 (70.0% of ARV)
$190,000$20,000$133,000$113,000$133,000 (70.0% of ARV)

The 70% factor is a guideline, not a law. In low-risk markets with accurate rehab estimates and strong rental demand, some investors stretch to 75%. In higher-risk markets or with uncertain ARV, investors demand 65% or lower. The right factor depends on your confidence in every input. When in doubt, be more conservative — the deals you pass on cost nothing; the deals you overpay for cost everything.

Step 3: Building the Rehab Budget

The rehab budget is the second most critical input in a BRRRR deal, and it is the input that is most frequently underestimated. A rehab budget that is 20 percent too low turns a deal that projects a $10,000 capital surplus into one that traps $4,000. Accurate rehab budgeting requires itemizing every repair, pricing materials and labor, and adding a contingency for unknown issues. A lump-sum estimate ("the rehab will be about $30,000") is not a budget; it is a guess. A line-item budget ("kitchen: $8,000, bathrooms: $5,000, flooring: $4,000, paint: $2,500, HVAC: $7,000, contingency: $3,500") is a budget.

For BRRRR specifically, the rehab should target rental-standard condition, not luxury. The goal is to bring the property to a condition that supports market rent and passes an appraisal — not to create a magazine-worthy home. Rental-standard renovations typically include: kitchen (RTA cabinets, granite or quartz countertops, stainless steel appliance package), bathrooms (new vanity, toilet, flooring, tub surround or shower), flooring (luxury vinyl plank throughout for durability), paint (neutral colors, interior and exterior), and any necessary major system repairs (roof, HVAC, plumbing, electrical). High-end finishes — custom cabinetry, premium flooring, upgraded fixtures — do not increase the appraisal proportionally to their cost and should be avoided in a BRRRR rehab.

The contingency is not optional. Every distressed property has issues that are not visible during the initial inspection: water damage behind walls, outdated wiring that fails inspection, plumbing leaks under the slab, termite damage in the framing. A 10 to 20 percent contingency (15 percent is a common standard) ensures these surprises do not blow the budget. For a $30,000 base rehab, a 15 percent contingency adds $4,500, bringing the total budget to $34,500. Investors who omit the contingency because they "do not expect surprises" are the ones who overrun the budget on every deal. Include the contingency, and if it is not needed, it becomes surplus at the refinance.

The table below shows a sample itemized rehab budget for a mid-market 3BR/2BA single-family home requiring a full cosmetic renovation plus HVAC replacement. This is the level of detail your rehab budget should have before you make an offer. Get at least one contractor bid for each major category, and verify material costs at a local supply store rather than relying on national averages, which can vary significantly by market.

CategoryDescriptionEstimated Cost
KitchenRTA cabinets, granite counters, stainless appliances, sink/faucet$8,500
Bathrooms (2)Vanities, toilets, LVP flooring, tub surrounds, fixtures$5,500
FlooringLVP throughout living areas and bedrooms (~1,400 sqft)$4,200
PaintInterior walls, ceilings, trim; exterior touch-up$2,800
HVACFull system replacement (furnace + AC + ductwork repairs)$7,000
Electrical/plumbingPanel update, fixture replacement, minor plumbing repairs$2,500
Curb appealLandscaping cleanup, exterior paint touch-up, front door$1,500
Permits & inspectionsElectrical, plumbing, HVAC permits + final inspection$1,000
SubtotalBase rehab cost$33,000
Contingency (15%)For unknown issues discovered during renovation$4,950
Total Rehab BudgetIncluding contingency$37,950

Step 4: Calculating Cash-Out Refinance Proceeds

The cash-out refinance is the mechanism that returns your invested capital. The loan amount is determined by two factors: the appraised value of the property (established by a professional appraisal ordered by the lender) and the lender's maximum loan-to-value (LTV) ratio for cash-out refinances on investment property. The formula is: Refinance Proceeds = Appraised Value × LTV. For a property appraised at $200,000 with a 75% LTV, the maximum loan is $150,000. If you have existing debt on the property (a hard money loan, for example), the refinance pays off that debt first and returns the remainder as cash to you.

Investment property cash-out refinances are typically limited to 70 to 75% LTV by conventional lenders (Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac guidelines), and 75 to 80% LTV by DSCR lenders. The higher the LTV, the more capital you recover — but the higher the monthly payment and the more risk of the property not cash flowing. The table below shows refinance proceeds at different LTV levels for a $200,000 appraised value. Note how a 5% change in LTV affects the loan amount — and therefore the capital recovered — by $10,000 on a $200,000 property.

The appraisal is the variable you cannot control — and it is the variable that most often causes BRRRR deals to fall short. The appraiser will use the same comparable sales methodology you used to estimate ARV, but the appraiser's selection of comparables, adjustments, and final value may differ from yours. If the appraisal comes in at your estimated ARV, the refinance proceeds match your projection. If it comes in lower, the proceeds are reduced, and you may not recover your full investment. This is why conservative ARV estimation and the 70% rule are so important — they build a margin of safety that absorbs a modest appraisal shortfall without trapping capital.

To prepare for the appraisal, provide the appraiser with a renovation summary (a one-page document listing all improvements made, with before-and-after photos) and a list of your comparable sales. Appraisers are not required to use your comparables, but providing them ensures the appraiser is aware of the most relevant recent sales. Be present for the appraisal if possible, walk the appraiser through the renovation, and answer questions professionally. A well-prepared appraisal can make the difference between a full capital recovery and a shortfall. For a detailed look at the appraisal process and lender requirements, see our cash-out refinancing in BRRRR article.

Appraised ValueLTVMax Loan AmountMonthly P&I (7.5%, 30yr)
$200,00070%$140,000$978
$200,00075%$150,000$1,050
$200,00080%$160,000$1,120
$210,00075%$157,500$1,101
$190,00075%$142,500$997

Hypothetical example: A property with a projected ARV of $200,000 and a total investment of $140,000 (purchase $110,000 + rehab $30,000). At 75% LTV, the refinance yields $150,000, recovering the full $140,000 investment plus a $10,000 surplus. If the appraisal comes in at $190,000 (a 5% shortfall), the 75% refinance yields $142,500 — still recovering the full investment, though the surplus shrinks to $2,500. If the appraisal comes in at $185,000, the refinance yields $138,750, and $1,250 of capital is trapped. The 70% rule provided enough cushion to absorb a 5% appraisal shortfall but not a 7.5% shortfall.

Step 5: Verifying Full Capital Recovery

The single most important calculation in a BRRRR deal is the verification that the refinance proceeds equal or exceed the total invested capital. This is the difference between a successful BRRRR (capital recovered, property retained) and a failed one (capital trapped, property held with money stuck in it). The formula is simple: Capital Recovered = Refinance Proceeds − Total Investment. If the result is zero or positive, the deal recovers your capital. If the result is negative, the absolute value is the amount of capital permanently trapped in the property.

Total investment includes: the purchase price, the rehab cost (including contingency), closing costs at purchase, holding costs during the rehab and seasoning period (property taxes, insurance, utilities, loan interest if using short-term financing), and the closing costs of the refinance itself. Many investors calculate total investment as just purchase + rehab and forget the holding and closing costs — which can add $5,000 to $15,000 to the actual investment and turn a deal that appears to recover capital into one that does not. Include every dollar you spend from the moment you buy the property to the moment the refinance closes.

Let us work through the full calculation for our hypothetical deal. Purchase price: $110,000. Rehab cost: $30,000 (using the base budget without contingency for simplicity). Purchase closing costs: $3,000. Holding costs (6 months of taxes, insurance, utilities, hard money interest): $6,000. Refinance closing costs: $4,000. Total investment: $110,000 + $30,000 + $3,000 + $6,000 + $4,000 = $153,000. At an ARV of $200,000 and 75% LTV, refinance proceeds are $150,000. Capital recovered: $150,000 − $153,000 = −$3,000. The deal leaves $3,000 trapped — it does NOT recover the full investment when all costs are included. This is why holding and closing costs matter, and why the 70% rule (which does not explicitly account for them) should be supplemented with a full total-investment calculation.

The table below shows the complete capital recovery calculation for three scenarios: the base case, a case with a higher purchase price, and a case with a lower appraisal. Notice how sensitive the outcome is to small changes — a $10,000 higher purchase price or a $10,000 lower appraisal can be the difference between full recovery and trapped capital. This sensitivity is why BRRRR demands precision: the margin for error is narrow, and every dollar matters.

Line ItemBase CaseHigher Purchase ($120K)Lower Appraisal ($190K)
Purchase price$110,000$120,000$110,000
Rehab cost$30,000$30,000$30,000
Purchase closing costs$3,000$3,000$3,000
Holding costs (6 months)$6,000$6,000$6,000
Refinance closing costs$4,000$4,000$4,000
Total investment$153,000$163,000$153,000
Appraised value (ARV)$200,000$200,000$190,000
Refinance @ 75% LTV$150,000$150,000$142,500
Capital recovered−$3,000−$13,000−$10,500
OutcomeCapital trappedCapital trappedCapital trapped

Warning: This example shows that even a deal that meets the 70% rule can leave capital trapped when holding costs and closing costs are included. The 70% rule is a quick filter, not a complete analysis. Always run the full total-investment calculation before making an offer, and include every dollar from purchase to refinance closing. A deal that leaves $3,000 trapped is manageable; one that leaves $13,000 trapped is not — and the difference is often in the costs that investors forget to include.

Adjusting the 70% Rule for Total Investment

Because the standard 70% rule does not explicitly account for closing costs, holding costs, and refinance costs, many experienced BRRRR investors use a modified version that includes these expenses. The modified formula is: Maximum Purchase Price = (ARV × Refinance LTV) − Rehab Cost − Closing Costs − Holding Costs − Refinance Costs. This formula ensures that the total investment, including all costs, does not exceed the refinance proceeds — guaranteeing full capital recovery.

Using our hypothetical deal with a refinance LTV of 75%, rehab of $30,000, purchase closing of $3,000, holding costs of $6,000, and refinance costs of $4,000: Maximum Purchase Price = ($200,000 × 0.75) − $30,000 − $3,000 − $6,000 − $4,000 = $150,000 − $43,000 = $107,000. This is $3,000 lower than the standard 70% rule calculation ($110,000), reflecting the $13,000 in additional costs that the 70% rule does not capture. Using the modified formula, a purchase at $107,000 produces a total investment of exactly $150,000, matching the refinance proceeds and achieving full capital recovery with zero surplus.

In practice, most investors use the 70% rule as a quick screen to eliminate deals that are clearly too expensive, then run the full total-investment calculation on deals that pass the screen. The 70% rule is fast and conservative enough for initial filtering; the full calculation is necessary before making an offer. Some investors use a 75% rule (ARV × 0.75 − rehab) as the quick screen, then adjust down for closing and holding costs in the full calculation. The specific approach matters less than the principle: always verify full capital recovery with a complete accounting of all costs before committing capital to a deal.

Post-Refinance Cash Flow and DSCR Verification

Full capital recovery is necessary but not sufficient. The refinanced property must also cash flow positively — meaning the rental income must exceed all operating expenses and the new debt service. A property that recovers your capital but cash flows negatively is a liability, not an asset: it drains money every month, and the drain may eventually force a sale at a loss. Before accepting any refinance, calculate the post-refinance cash flow and DSCR to confirm the property is sustainable as a long-term rental.

DSCR (Debt Service Coverage Ratio) is the metric lenders use to evaluate whether a property's income supports its debt service. The formula is: DSCR = Net Operating Income (NOI) ÷ Annual Debt Service. A DSCR of 1.00 means the income exactly covers the debt service — no margin for error. A DSCR of 1.20 means the income exceeds the debt service by 20%, providing a cushion for expense increases or vacancy. Most DSCR lenders require a minimum DSCR of 1.20; conventional lenders verify the same concept through your personal debt-to-income ratio. A DSCR below 1.20 is a warning sign that the property may not be sustainable at the refinanced loan amount.

Let us calculate the post-refinance DSCR for our hypothetical deal. The property rents for $1,900 per month ($22,800 per year). Annual operating expenses (property taxes $2,400, insurance $1,440, property management at 8% = $1,824, vacancy reserve at 5% = $1,140, maintenance/CapEx reserve at 8% = $1,824) total approximately $8,628. NOI = $22,800 − $8,628 = $14,172. The refinance loan of $150,000 at 7.5% interest on a 30-year amortization has an annual debt service of approximately $12,600 ($1,050 × 12). DSCR = $14,172 ÷ $12,600 = 1.125. This is below the 1.20 minimum — the deal recovers capital but does not produce a strong enough DSCR to qualify with most DSCR lenders or to provide adequate cushion.

The issue is that the refinance loan amount ($150,000) is too high relative to the rent ($1,900/month). There are two solutions: reduce the loan amount (leave some capital in the property to lower the payment and improve DSCR), or increase the rent (if the market supports more than $1,900). If we reduce the loan to $140,000, the annual debt service drops to approximately $11,760, the DSCR improves to 1.205 (just above the minimum), and cash flow improves to $2,412/year ($201/month) — but $13,000 of capital remains trapped. If we increase the rent to $2,100/month ($25,200/year), NOI rises to $16,572, DSCR improves to 1.316, and cash flow increases to $3,972/year ($331/month) — but only if the market supports $2,100. This is the essential BRRRR tension: maximizing capital recovery (higher loan) conflicts with maximizing cash flow sustainability (lower loan). The right balance depends on your goals, the lender's requirements, and the market rent.

ScenarioLoan AmountMonthly P&IAnnual Debt ServiceNOIDSCRMonthly Cash Flow
$150K loan, $1,900 rent$150,000$1,050$12,600$14,1721.13$130
$140K loan, $1,900 rent$140,000$980$11,760$14,1721.21$201
$150K loan, $2,100 rent$150,000$1,050$12,600$16,5721.32$331
$140K loan, $2,100 rent$140,000$980$11,760$16,5721.41$401
$160K loan, $2,100 rent$160,000$1,120$13,440$16,5721.23$261

A DSCR of 1.20 is the minimum that most lenders require, but a stronger DSCR (1.30 or higher) provides a meaningful cushion against expense increases, vacancy, and rent reductions. When evaluating a BRRRR deal, target a post-refinance DSCR of at least 1.25 to ensure the property is sustainable through normal adversity. If the maximum refinance loan produces a DSCR below 1.20, reduce the loan amount and accept some trapped capital — a cash-flowing property with trapped capital is better than a cash-flow-negative property with full capital recovery.

A Complete Worked BRRRR Deal

Let us assemble all five calculations into a complete worked BRRRR deal, from ARV estimation through post-refinance cash flow. This is the analysis you should run on every BRRRR before making an offer. The property is a 3BR/2BA, 1,400 sqft single-family home in a mid-market neighborhood, currently distressed and listed for $125,000.

Step 1 — ARV: Based on 4 comparable renovated sales within 0.5 miles in the last 9 months, adjusted for differences, we estimate ARV at $200,000 (conservative, from a range of $200,000–$210,000). Step 2 — Rehab Budget: Based on an itemized scope of work with contractor bids, we estimate $30,000 in base rehab plus a 15% contingency of $4,500, for a total rehab budget of $34,500. Step 3 — Maximum Purchase Price (70% rule): ($200,000 × 0.70) − $34,500 = $140,000 − $34,500 = $105,500. The property is listed at $125,000 — above our maximum. We offer $105,500 and negotiate.

Step 4 — Total Investment and Capital Recovery: Assuming we purchase at $105,500, total investment is: purchase $105,500 + rehab $34,500 + purchase closing $3,000 + holding costs (6 months) $6,000 + refinance closing $4,000 = $153,000. Refinance at 75% LTV of $200,000 ARV = $150,000. Capital recovered: $150,000 − $153,000 = −$3,000. The deal leaves $3,000 trapped even at the 70%-rule purchase price, due to closing and holding costs. We negotiate the purchase price down to $102,000, reducing total investment to $149,500, and capital recovered becomes $150,000 − $149,500 = +$500. Full capital recovery achieved with a small surplus.

Step 5 — Post-Refinance Cash Flow: The property rents for $2,000/month ($24,000/year). Annual operating expenses total approximately $8,760. NOI = $24,000 − $8,760 = $15,240. Annual debt service on $150,000 at 7.5%, 30-year = $12,600. DSCR = $15,240 ÷ $12,600 = 1.21. Monthly cash flow = ($15,240 − $12,600) ÷ 12 = $220/month. The deal achieves full capital recovery, a DSCR above 1.20, and positive monthly cash flow — a successful BRRRR. The table below summarizes the complete deal.

MetricValueNotes
ARV (estimated)$200,000Conservative, from 4 comparable sales
Rehab budget (with 15% contingency)$34,500Itemized scope of work
Max purchase price (70% rule)$105,500($200K × 0.70) − $34,500
Negotiated purchase price$102,000Below 70% rule maximum
Total investment (all costs)$149,500Purchase + rehab + closing + holding + refi
Refinance @ 75% LTV$150,000$200,000 ARV × 0.75
Capital recovered+$500Full capital recovery achieved
Monthly rent$2,000Market rent for renovated 3BR/2BA
Annual NOI$15,240Rent minus operating expenses
Annual debt service$12,600$150K at 7.5%, 30-year amortization
Post-refi DSCR1.21Above 1.20 lender minimum
Monthly cash flow$220Positive and sustainable

Hypothetical example summary: A distressed 3BR/2BA purchased for $102,000, renovated for $34,500, rented for $2,000/month, and refinanced at $150,000 (75% LTV of $200,000 ARV) achieves full capital recovery ($500 surplus), a DSCR of 1.21, and $220/month in positive cash flow. This is a successful BRRRR — but note how narrow the margins are. A $10,000 appraisal shortfall would trap $9,500; a $5,000 rehab overrun would trap $4,500. The deal works because the purchase price was negotiated below the 70% rule maximum, providing a margin of safety.

Sensitivity Analysis: What If the Numbers Change?

Because BRRRR margins are narrow, sensitivity analysis — testing how the deal performs under different assumptions — is essential before committing capital. The three variables most likely to differ from your projections are the appraisal (ARV), the rehab cost, and the market rent. Testing each of these at conservative, expected, and pessimistic values tells you whether the deal survives normal adversity or fails under modest stress.

The table below shows a sensitivity analysis for our worked deal, varying the appraisal and rehab cost while holding rent constant at $2,000/month. The "capital recovered" row shows whether the refinance returns the full investment. The "DSCR" row shows whether the property cash flows sustainably. A deal that recovers capital and achieves DSCR ≥ 1.20 under the expected scenario but fails under the pessimistic scenario is a marginal deal — proceed only if you have reserves to cover the shortfall. A deal that succeeds even under the pessimistic scenario is a strong deal — proceed with confidence.

The worst-case scenario — a $15,000 appraisal shortfall combined with a $5,500 rehab overrun — leaves $16,250 trapped and produces a DSCR of 1.09, which would not qualify with most lenders. This is why the 70% rule and conservative estimation are so important: they are not just about the expected case, they are about ensuring the deal survives the pessimistic case. If the worst-case scenario would leave you with trapped capital you cannot afford to leave in the deal, the deal is too risky for your situation. Use the deal analysis tools available through REIVaultPro to run sensitivity scenarios quickly and compare multiple deals side by side. For a comprehensive look at what to do when deals go wrong, see our BRRRR risks and exit strategies article.

ScenarioAppraisalRehab CostTotal InvestmentRefi @ 75%Capital RecoveredPost-Refi DSCR
Optimistic$210,000$30,000$145,000$157,500+$12,5001.33
Expected$200,000$34,500$149,500$150,000+$5001.21
Pessimistic (low appraisal)$190,000$34,500$149,500$142,500−$7,0001.13
Pessimistic (rehab overrun)$200,000$40,000$155,000$150,000−$5,0001.21
Worst case (both)$185,000$40,000$155,000$138,750−$16,2501.09

Tools and Resources for BRRRR Calculation

Accurate BRRRR calculation requires more than mental math. A spreadsheet or dedicated calculator allows you to test scenarios quickly, compare deals, and avoid arithmetic errors that can be costly. At minimum, your BRRRR calculator should include inputs for ARV, purchase price, rehab budget (itemized), closing costs, holding costs, refinance LTV, interest rate, amortization, market rent, and operating expenses — and should output total investment, refinance proceeds, capital recovered, post-refinance DSCR, and monthly cash flow.

REIVaultPro offers a BRRRR calculator that handles all of these inputs and produces the complete output set, with built-in sensitivity analysis for appraisal and rehab variations. The MortgageStrategist platform provides refinance-specific tools that compare lender offers on rate, LTV, seasoning, and closing costs — helping you identify the lender whose terms produce the best capital recovery outcome for a specific deal. Using these tools before making an offer, and updating them as actual numbers replace estimates, is the difference between disciplined deal analysis and hopeful guesswork.

Beyond tools, the most valuable resource is a track record of your own deals. After each BRRRR, compare your projected numbers to the actual numbers — the actual purchase price, the actual rehab cost, the actual appraisal, the actual refinance proceeds, the actual rent. The gap between projection and reality is your education. Investors who track this gap over multiple deals discover their systematic biases (consistently overestimating ARV, consistently underestimating rehab) and can correct them. Investors who do not track the gap repeat the same errors indefinitely. For a broader framework on tracking portfolio performance, see our cash flow analysis article.

Conclusion

BRRRR deal calculation is not complex, but it is unforgiving. The strategy depends on a precise sequence of five calculations — ARV, maximum purchase price, rehab budget, refinance proceeds, and post-refinance cash flow — each of which must be accurate for the deal to work. An overestimated ARV, an underestimated rehab, an ignored closing cost, or an unverified DSCR can each be the difference between a successful capital recovery and a property with money permanently trapped. The 70% rule provides a quick screen, but it is not a complete analysis: only a full total-investment calculation that includes every dollar from purchase to refinance closing can confirm that the deal recovers your capital. And only a post-refinance DSCR calculation can confirm that the property is sustainable as a long-term rental. The worked deal in this article — a $102,000 purchase, $34,500 rehab, $200,000 ARV, $150,000 refinance — shows how narrow the margins are: a $500 capital surplus and a 1.21 DSCR in the expected case, but $7,000 to $16,000 trapped in pessimistic scenarios. This is the nature of BRRRR: the strategy works when the math is right, and it fails quietly when the math is wrong. The investors who succeed are those who calculate conservatively, include every cost, run sensitivity analysis, and walk away from deals that do not pencil out — even when the deal is exciting or the market is hot. Use the 70% rule as a screen, the full total-investment calculation as your decision tool, and the DSCR as your sustainability check. Run the numbers on every deal, track your projections against reality, and let the math — not the emotion — decide. This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, or financial advice. Consult a licensed mortgage professional, a qualified real estate attorney, and a tax advisor for guidance specific to your situation.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the 70% rule in BRRRR and why does it matter?

The 70% rule states that a BRRRR investor should pay no more than 70% of the after-repair value (ARV) minus the estimated rehab costs. The formula is: Maximum Purchase Price = (ARV × 0.70) − Rehab Cost. The rule matters because it ensures you buy at a deep enough discount that a cash-out refinance at 75-80% LTV will return your full invested capital. If your total investment (purchase + rehab) equals 70% of ARV and you refinance at 75% of ARV, the loan proceeds exceed your investment, recovering your capital with a surplus. The 70% factor also provides a margin of safety against appraisal shortfalls and rehab overruns. Without this margin, even modest errors in ARV or rehab estimates can leave capital permanently trapped in the property.

How do I estimate after-repair value (ARV) accurately?

ARV is estimated using comparable sales analysis: identify 3 to 5 properties that have sold in the last 6 to 12 months, within 0.5 to 1 mile of your subject property, with similar characteristics (bedroom/bathroom count, square footage within 15%, property type and age). For each comparable, note the sale price and adjust for differences from your subject property — add or subtract for size, condition, features, and location differences. Average the adjusted sale prices to arrive at your ARV. For a BRRRR, use comparables that are in renovated condition (not other distressed properties), and be conservative: if your analysis suggests a range, use the lower end. The most common ARV error is cherry-picking the highest comparable and ignoring the rest — an appraiser will use all relevant comparables, so your estimate should too. For a detailed methodology, see our after-repair value analysis article.

What costs should I include in my total BRRRR investment?

Your total investment includes every dollar spent from the moment you buy the property to the moment the refinance closes. This includes: the purchase price, the rehab cost (including contingency), purchase closing costs (title, escrow, inspection, lender fees), holding costs during the rehab and seasoning period (property taxes, insurance, utilities, and loan interest if using short-term financing), and the refinance closing costs (appraisal, title, lender fees). Many investors calculate total investment as just purchase + rehab and forget the holding and closing costs, which can add $5,000 to $15,000. This omission turns a deal that appears to recover capital into one that does not. Always include every cost in your total investment calculation before deciding whether a deal recovers your capital.

What LTV should I use when calculating refinance proceeds?

Most conventional lenders (Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac guidelines) limit cash-out refinances on investment property to 70-75% LTV. DSCR lenders, which specialize in investment property financing, typically allow 75-80% LTV. Use the LTV that matches the lender you plan to use — if you have not yet identified a lender, use 75% as a conservative default. The LTV directly determines how much capital you recover: on a $200,000 appraisal, the difference between 70% LTV ($140,000) and 80% LTV ($160,000) is $20,000. Higher LTV means more capital recovered but a higher monthly payment and potentially lower DSCR. Always verify your lender's maximum LTV before running your deal math, and use the MortgageStrategist platform to compare lender offers.

What DSCR do I need after the cash-out refinance?

Most DSCR lenders require a minimum DSCR of 1.20, meaning the property's net operating income must be at least 20% greater than the annual debt service. A DSCR of 1.00 means income exactly covers the debt service with no margin; a DSCR below 1.00 means the property loses money each month. While 1.20 is the lender minimum, a stronger DSCR of 1.30 or higher provides a meaningful cushion against expense increases, vacancy, and rent reductions. If your maximum refinance loan produces a DSCR below 1.20, you should either reduce the loan amount (accepting some trapped capital to improve cash flow) or increase the rent (if the market supports it). A property that recovers capital but cash flows negatively is a liability, not an asset.

Can I still do BRRRR if the deal does not fully recover my capital?

Yes, but it changes the deal from a "free" property to one with some of your capital permanently invested. If a deal leaves $5,000 to $10,000 trapped, you still own a cash-flowing rental property — you just have capital tied up that cannot be redeployed. The question is whether the trapped capital earns an acceptable return. If $8,000 is trapped and the property generates $3,000/year in cash flow, the cash-on-cash return on the trapped capital is 37.5% — quite good. If $20,000 is trapped and the property generates $1,200/year, the return is 6% — marginal. The key is to track trapped capital across all your deals: if your BRRRRs consistently leave large amounts trapped, your purchase prices are too high or your ARV estimates are too optimistic, and you should adjust your criteria before scaling. See our BRRRR risks article for a full discussion of partial recovery scenarios.

Learn with Ebonie Caldwell

Keep building your investing knowledge

This guide is part of Ebonie Caldwell's real estate investing education series. Explore the contributor profile for more practical lessons, tools, and courses.

Explore Ebonie's education

Real Estate Investing Software & Education

Explore Real Estate Investment Tools

Visit REIVaultPro.com for professional services and resources.

Visit Site

This is a promotional link to an affiliated business of the publisher, separate from the magazine's editorial content.

Editorial Disclosure: This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute investment, tax, or legal advice. All financial examples are hypothetical illustrations and do not represent guaranteed returns. Real estate investments involve risk, including the potential loss of principal. Consult with qualified professionals before making investment decisions. Cross-marketing links to affiliated businesses are separate from editorial content.

Ebonie Caldwell

Ebonie Caldwell

Real Estate & Mortgage Strategist | Real Estate Investor & Educator

Ebonie Caldwell has 25+ years of real estate and mortgage industry experience, including real estate investing, mortgage underwriting, real estate education, financing, and investment strategies. She has provided real estate investing education to more than 14,000 students.

More in BRRRR Strategy

Affiliated resource

REI Invest Capital — Property Selling & Investment Resources

Explore off-market real estate, property selling options, investor financing information, and real estate partnership opportunities.

Visit REI Invest Capital

REI Invest Capital is an affiliated business resource of the publisher. Availability, terms, and outcomes are not guaranteed. Review information independently before making a property or financing decision.