The single most important number in any fix-and-flip deal is the price you pay for the property. Every other variable — the rehab budget, the carrying costs, the selling costs, the eventual sale price — can be managed, optimized, and adjusted, but the purchase price is locked in at closing. If you overpay, no amount of skilled renovation, aggressive marketing, or market appreciation will recover the lost margin. If you underpay (buy at a deep enough discount), the deal has the structural margin to absorb cost overruns, timeline delays, and ARV shortfalls while remaining profitable. This is why experienced flippers spend more time on offer calculation than on any other part of the deal — and why the 70% rule has become the industry-standard formula for determining the maximum allowable offer (MAO).
The 70% rule is elegantly simple: an investor should pay no more than 70 percent of the after-repair value (ARV) minus the estimated rehab costs. The formula — MAO = (ARV × 0.70) − Rehab Cost — packs a remarkable amount of financial logic into a single line. The 70 percent factor accounts for all the costs that sit between the purchase and the sale: the rehab itself, closing costs on both the purchase and the sale, carrying costs during the hold (interest, taxes, insurance, utilities), selling costs (commissions, concessions, transfer taxes), and the profit margin the investor requires to justify the risk and effort. The remaining 30 percent of ARV is the buffer that makes the deal work — and if that buffer is too thin, the deal is too risky to pursue.
But while the formula is simple, the inputs are not. The ARV must be estimated accurately using comparable sales analysis, not wishful thinking. The rehab cost must be estimated using a detailed scope of work, not a ballpark guess. And the 70 percent factor itself may need adjustment based on market conditions, deal complexity, financing costs, and the investor's risk tolerance. An investor who applies the formula with sloppy inputs gets a precise-looking number that is precisely wrong — and the error is not discovered until the property is listed for sale and the profit has evaporated. The discipline of offer calculation is not in the arithmetic; it is in the quality of the inputs and the honesty with which they are estimated.
This guide walks through every component of the flip offer calculation in detail: how to estimate ARV using comparable sales, how to build an accurate rehab cost estimate, how to account for closing costs and carrying costs, how to set the profit margin, and how to adjust the 70% factor for different deal scenarios. We will work through multiple step-by-step examples with real numbers, and we will address the common errors that cause offer calculations to produce bad numbers. For the broader fix-and-flip process, see our fix-and-flip complete guide. For the financing costs that feed into the calculation, see our flip financing options article. And for the post-sale profit analysis that validates the calculation, see our flip profit and loss analysis article. Whether you are calculating your first MAO or refining your offer model, the framework that follows is designed to help you make offers with confidence and protect your profit before you ever commit capital.
The 70% Rule: Formula and Logic
The 70% rule states that a fix-and-flip investor should pay no more than 70 percent of the after-repair value (ARV) of a property, minus the estimated rehab costs. The formula is: Maximum Allowable Offer (MAO) = (ARV × 0.70) − Rehab Cost. For example, if a property will be worth $250,000 after renovation and the rehab costs $40,000, the MAO is ($250,000 × 0.70) − $40,000 = $175,000 − $40,000 = $135,000. If you can buy the property for $135,000 or less, the deal meets the 70% rule.
The logic behind the 70 percent factor is that the remaining 30 percent of ARV must cover all costs other than the purchase and rehab — plus the investor's profit. In a typical flip, those costs break down approximately as follows: purchase closing costs (1–3% of ARV), carrying costs during the hold (3–5% of ARV), selling costs including commissions and concessions (8–10% of ARV), and the investor's profit margin (10–15% of ARV). These sum to approximately 22 to 33 percent of ARV — which is why 70 percent is the standard factor. It provides just enough room for all costs and a meaningful profit, with a small margin of safety against cost overruns and ARV shortfalls.
The 70 percent factor is a guideline, not a physical law. In markets with lower selling costs (e.g., FSBO or flat-fee listings), faster sale timelines (lower carrying costs), or cheaper financing, an investor may stretch to 75 percent. In markets with higher risk (expensive financing, uncertain ARV, volatile demand), the investor may demand 65 percent or lower. The right factor depends on the specific cost structure of the deal and the investor's risk tolerance — but the principle is constant: the total of purchase plus rehab plus all other costs must leave a meaningful profit margin, and if it does not, the deal does not work. The table below shows how the 70% factor translates to MAO across a range of ARV and rehab cost scenarios.
| ARV | Rehab Cost | MAO at 70% | Total Cost (Purchase + Rehab) | Gross Spread (ARV − Total) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $250,000 | $40,000 | $135,000 | $175,000 | $75,000 |
| $200,000 | $30,000 | $110,000 | $140,000 | $60,000 |
| $300,000 | $50,000 | $160,000 | $210,000 | $90,000 |
| $180,000 | $25,000 | $101,000 | $126,000 | $54,000 |
| $350,000 | $65,000 | $180,000 | $245,000 | $105,000 |
| $220,000 | $35,000 | $119,000 | $154,000 | $66,000 |
The 70% rule is a quick-screen tool, not a complete deal analysis. It tells you whether a deal is worth pursuing — whether the gross spread is large enough to likely cover all costs and leave a profit. Before making an actual offer, run a full deal analysis that itemizes every cost (purchase closing, carrying, selling, financing) to confirm the net profit. The 70% rule gets you into the right ballpark; the full analysis confirms the deal.
Step 1: Estimating the After-Repair Value (ARV)
The ARV is the first input in the MAO formula, and it is the input that most often causes offers to be wrong. The ARV is the price at which the property will sell after the renovation is complete, in the current market, within a reasonable timeframe (typically 30 to 90 days on market). It is not the price you hope to get, the price of the nicest home on the block, or the price from a year ago. It is the price that a willing, informed buyer will pay for a renovated property of this size, in this location, in this condition, today.
To estimate ARV, pull at least four to six comparable sales (comps) from the MLS or a real estate data platform. Comps must meet three criteria: proximity (within 0.5 miles, ideally in the same neighborhood and school district), similarity (same bedroom/bathroom count, similar square footage within 15 percent, similar lot size and property type), and recency (sold within the last 90 days, or 180 days maximum in slower markets). If you cannot find enough sold comps, use active listings and pending sales as secondary data points — but recognize that list prices and pending prices are not confirmed sale prices, and adjust accordingly. Active listings above the sold comp range suggest the market may be softening; pending sales near the sold range confirm the market is holding.
After pulling your comps, adjust each one for differences from the subject property. A comp with one fewer bathroom adjusts downward by $5,000 to $10,000 (meaning your property is worth $5,000 to $10,000 more than that comp sold for). A comp on a busy street adjusts upward by $3,000 to $7,000 when comparing to your quieter location. A comp that is 200 square feet larger adjusts downward by the price per square foot. A comp with an updated kitchen adjusts upward by $5,000 to $10,000 if your kitchen will be similarly updated. After adjusting, take the median (not the average, which is skewed by outliers) of the adjusted comp values as your ARV estimate. Then apply a 3 to 5 percent downward safety adjustment to account for possible market softening between your purchase and your sale — because the market can change during the 4 to 9 months you hold the property.
- Pull 4–6 sold comps within 0.5 miles, same neighborhood, same bed/bath, within 15% square footage.
- Use only comps sold within the last 90 days (180 days max in slower markets).
- Adjust each comp for differences: bath count, lot size, garage, busy street, condition, age of renovation.
- Use the median adjusted comp value, not the average — the median is less skewed by outlier comps.
- Apply a 3–5% downward safety adjustment to the median to account for possible market softening.
- Never use the highest comp as your ARV — it represents the best-case, not the likely outcome.
Step 2: Estimating Rehab Costs
The rehab cost is the second input in the MAO formula, and it is the input that most frequently causes deals to go over budget. Underestimating rehab costs means you spend more than planned, increasing your total project cost and reducing or eliminating your profit. Overestimating means you may pass on good deals or make unnecessarily low offers that get rejected. An accurate rehab estimate requires a disciplined process — walking the property with a contractor, itemizing every repair, and adding a contingency — not a guess based on square footage or photos.
The most reliable method for estimating rehab costs is to walk the property with a licensed contractor before making an offer. Create an itemized scope of work that lists every repair by category: kitchen, bathrooms, flooring, paint, roofing, HVAC, plumbing, electrical, windows, doors, landscaping, and permits. For each category, specify the materials and the labor, and get a written estimate. The table below shows a typical rehab cost breakdown for a mid-market single-family home requiring a full cosmetic renovation. Your actual costs will vary by market, property condition, and scope — use these ranges as a starting point, then refine with contractor bids for your specific property.
Always include a contingency reserve of 10 to 20 percent of the estimated rehab cost for unknown issues discovered during the renovation. Every distressed property has surprises behind the walls and under the floors: water damage, termite damage, outdated wiring, plumbing leaks, structural issues. A $40,000 rehab estimate with a 15 percent contingency becomes a $46,000 budget — and if the surprises are minor, the unused contingency becomes additional profit. If the surprises are significant, the contingency absorbs the cost without derailing the deal. For a detailed guide to rehab budgeting by category, see our flip rehab budgeting article.
| Rehab Category | Low End | High End | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kitchen (cabinets, counters, appliances) | $8,000 | $20,000 | Highest-impact renovation for buyer appeal |
| Bathrooms (1–2 full baths) | $4,000 | $12,000 | Second-most-scrutinized space after kitchen |
| Flooring (LVP or hardwood) | $4,000 | $10,000 | Consistent flooring throughout increases value |
| Interior paint (whole house) | $2,000 | $5,000 | Neutral colors; cheapest value-add per dollar |
| Exterior paint and curb appeal | $2,000 | $6,000 | First impressions drive buyer interest |
| Roof (if replacement needed) | $6,000 | $12,000 | Buyers and lenders require a sound roof |
| HVAC (if replacement needed) | $5,000 | $10,000 | Required for buyer financing in most cases |
| Plumbing/electrical repairs | $1,500 | $6,000 | Address code issues and functional failures |
| Permits and inspections | $500 | $3,000 | Required for structural, electrical, plumbing |
| Contingency (10–20%) | $3,000 | $8,000 | For unknown issues behind walls and floors |
| Total (typical full cosmetic) | $36,000 | $92,000 | Varies by size, condition, and market |
Warning: Estimating rehab costs from photos or drive-bys is the single most common cause of offer miscalculation. A property that looks like it needs "paint and flooring" may have water damage, outdated electrical, or a failing roof that adds $15,000 to the rehab. Always walk the property with a contractor before submitting an offer — the cost of the contractor walk-through ($0–$200) is trivial compared to the cost of a $15,000 rehab underestimate.
Step 3: Accounting for Closing and Carrying Costs
Closing costs and carrying costs are the expenses that sit between the purchase and the sale, and they are the costs that flippers most frequently omit from the offer calculation — only to discover them at the sale, when they have already consumed a chunk of the projected profit. A disciplined offer calculation includes these costs explicitly, not as an afterthought. If they are not accounted for at the offer stage, the MAO will be too high and the deal will be marginally profitable at best.
Closing costs on the purchase typically run 1 to 3 percent of the purchase price and include title insurance, escrow fees, recording fees, transfer taxes (in some states), and inspection costs. On a $135,000 purchase, expect $2,000 to $4,000 in closing costs. Closing costs on the sale are significantly higher — typically 8 to 10 percent of the sale price — because they include the real estate commission (5 to 6 percent), buyer concessions (1 to 3 percent), and transfer taxes and title fees (0.5 to 1 percent). On a $250,000 sale, expect $20,000 to $25,000 in selling costs. These are not optional expenses; they are the cost of transacting in real estate, and they must be in the offer math from the start.
Carrying costs are the monthly expenses of owning the property during the hold period: loan interest (if financed), property taxes, insurance, utilities (water, gas, electricity, trash), and maintenance (lawn, snow). For a property financed with a $120,000 hard money loan at 12 percent, carrying costs run approximately $1,500 to $2,000 per month. Over a typical 5-month hold (2 months rehab, 3 months listing and closing), total carrying costs reach $7,500 to $10,000. The exact amount depends on the loan balance, interest rate, local tax rates, utility costs, and the timeline — but the key principle is that carrying costs are real, they accumulate monthly, and they must be budgeted in the offer calculation, not discovered at the sale.
| Cost Category | Calculation Method | Typical Range | Example ($250K ARV, $135K Purchase) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Purchase closing costs | 1–3% of purchase price | $2,000–$4,000 | $3,000 |
| Selling costs (commissions, concessions) | 8–10% of sale price | $20,000–$25,000 | $21,250 |
| Carrying costs (monthly) | $1,500–$2,000/month × hold months | $7,500–$10,000 (5 mo.) | $9,225 |
| Financing costs (points) | 1–3% of loan amount (upfront) | $1,200–$3,600 | $2,400 |
| Total non-rehab costs | Sum of all above | $30,700–$42,600 | $35,875 |
Hypothetical example: On a $250,000 ARV flip with a $135,000 purchase and $40,000 rehab, the non-rehab costs total approximately $35,875 (purchase closing, selling costs, carrying, and financing). The gross spread is $250,000 − $135,000 − $40,000 = $75,000. After deducting the $35,875 in non-rehab costs, the net profit is $39,125. If these costs had been omitted from the offer calculation, the investor would have projected $75,000 in profit — nearly double the actual result. This is why every cost must be in the calculation, not just the purchase and rehab.
Step 4: Setting the Profit Margin
The profit margin is the amount of money the flipper expects to earn from the deal after all costs are deducted. It is not a residual — whatever is left over — but a target that should be built into the offer calculation from the start. If the deal does not support the target profit margin at the calculated MAO, the deal does not work, and the investor should walk away or lower the offer. Setting the profit margin explicitly forces the investor to ask: "Is this deal worth the risk and effort for this amount of money?"
Profit margins in fix-and-flip are typically expressed as a percentage of ARV or as a percentage of total project cost. A common target for mid-market flips is $25,000 to $40,000 in net profit per deal, which translates to approximately 10 to 15 percent of ARV or 20 to 25 percent of total project cost. For higher-priced or more complex deals, the target should be higher ($50,000 to $75,000+) because the risk, capital, and time commitment are greater. For entry-level or lower-priced deals, the target may be lower ($15,000 to $25,000) but should never be so low that a single cost overrun or ARV miss eliminates the profit entirely.
The profit margin must be proportional to the risk. A flip with a reliable ARV, a straightforward cosmetic rehab, a proven contractor, and a fast sale timeline carries lower risk and may justify a thinner margin. A flip with an uncertain ARV, a complex structural rehab, an unproven contractor, or a softening market carries higher risk and demands a thicker margin. Investors who set the same profit target for every deal regardless of risk are not pricing risk correctly — and over time, the risky deals with thin margins will produce losses that wipe out the profits from the safe deals. The 70% rule builds in a default margin, but the investor should always verify that the margin is adequate for the specific deal's risk profile.
- Target $25,000–$40,000 net profit for mid-market flips (10–15% of ARV).
- Target higher margins ($50,000+) for higher-priced or more complex/risky deals.
- Target lower margins ($15,000–$25,000) only for entry-level deals with low risk.
- Never accept a margin so thin that a single cost overrun or ARV miss eliminates the profit.
- Adjust the margin target upward for deals with uncertain ARV, complex rehab, or softening markets.
- Build the profit margin into the offer calculation explicitly — do not treat it as a residual.
The Complete MAO Formula: Putting It All Together
The 70% rule is a simplified version of a more complete offer calculation that itemizes every cost. The simplified formula — MAO = (ARV × 0.70) − Rehab — is useful for quick screening, but the complete formula is: MAO = ARV − Rehab Cost − Purchase Closing Costs − Selling Costs − Carrying Costs − Financing Costs − Profit Margin. This formula subtracts every known cost from the ARV to arrive at the maximum purchase price that still supports the target profit. The 70% rule approximates this by using a flat 30% factor for all non-purchase costs plus profit, but the complete formula is more precise because it uses actual cost estimates rather than a percentage assumption.
Let us work through a complete example using both methods to see how they compare. The deal: ARV is $250,000, rehab is $40,000, purchase closing costs are $3,000, selling costs are $21,250 (8.5% of ARV), carrying costs are $9,225 (5 months at $1,845/month), financing costs are $2,400 (2 points on $120,000), and the target profit margin is $35,000. Using the complete formula: MAO = $250,000 − $40,000 − $3,000 − $21,250 − $9,225 − $2,400 − $35,000 = $139,125. Using the 70% rule: MAO = ($250,000 × 0.70) − $40,000 = $135,000. The 70% rule produces a slightly more conservative MAO ($135,000 vs. $139,125) because it uses a flat 30% for all non-rehab costs, while the complete formula uses specific cost estimates that happen to sum to slightly less than 30%.
The two methods will diverge more significantly when the actual costs differ from the 30% assumption. If selling costs are higher (e.g., a buyer's market requiring 3% in concessions), or carrying costs are higher (a longer timeline or more expensive financing), the complete formula will produce a lower MAO than the 70% rule — correctly reflecting the higher cost structure. If costs are lower (a flat-fee listing, fast sale, cheap financing), the complete formula will produce a higher MAO. The best practice is to use the 70% rule for quick screening and the complete formula for the final offer — this gives you both speed and precision.
| Component | Amount | Calculation |
|---|---|---|
| ARV (sale price) | $250,000 | Median of adjusted comparable sales |
| Less: Rehab cost | −$40,000 | Itemized scope of work + 15% contingency |
| Less: Purchase closing costs | −$3,000 | Title, escrow, recording, inspection |
| Less: Selling costs | −$21,250 | 6% commission + 2% concessions + 0.5% transfer |
| Less: Carrying costs (5 months) | −$9,225 | $1,845/month × 5 months |
| Less: Financing costs (2 points) | −$2,400 | 2% of $120,000 hard money loan |
| Less: Target profit margin | −$35,000 | 14% of ARV, target for mid-market flip |
| MAO (maximum allowable offer) | $139,125 | ARV minus all costs and profit |
| 70% rule MAO (for comparison) | $135,000 | (ARV × 0.70) − Rehab |
Use the 70% rule to screen deals quickly — if a property's asking price is above the 70% MAO, move on without spending more time. Use the complete formula to finalize your offer — it accounts for the specific cost structure of the deal and produces a more precise MAO. When the two methods produce different numbers, use the lower (more conservative) MAO to protect your margin.
Adjusting the 70% Factor for Different Deals
The 70 percent factor is a default that works for typical mid-market flips with standard cost structures. But not every deal is typical, and the factor should be adjusted up or down based on the specific cost structure and risk profile of the deal. Understanding when and how to adjust is what separates a mechanical application of the rule from a thoughtful one.
Adjust the factor downward (to 65% or lower) when: the deal carries higher risk (uncertain ARV, complex structural rehab, unproven contractor), the financing is expensive (high hard money rates, multiple points), the market is softening (increasing days on market, declining prices), or the timeline is likely to be long (large rehab, slow permitting, off-season sale). A lower factor produces a lower MAO — a more conservative offer that builds in a larger margin of safety. For example, at 65%, the MAO for a $250,000 ARV with $40,000 rehab is ($250,000 × 0.65) − $40,000 = $122,500 — $12,500 less than the 70% MAO, providing an additional $12,500 in safety margin.
Adjust the factor upward (to 75%) only when: the deal carries lower risk (confirmed ARV with strong comps, simple cosmetic rehab, proven contractor), the financing is cheap (cash or low-rate private money), the market is strong (fast sales, rising prices), and the timeline is likely to be short (small rehab, fast permitting, peak-season sale). Even then, be cautious — the 75% factor leaves only 25% for all non-purchase costs and profit, which is a thin margin. For example, at 75%, the MAO for a $250,000 ARV with $40,000 rehab is ($250,000 × 0.75) − $40,000 = $147,500 — $12,500 more than the 70% MAO, but with $12,500 less safety margin. Most experienced flippers rarely go above 72% and never above 75%, regardless of how good the deal looks.
| Factor | MAO ($250K ARV, $40K Rehab) | Safety Margin (% of ARV) | When to Use |
|---|---|---|---|
| 65% | $122,500 | 35% | High risk: uncertain ARV, complex rehab, soft market |
| 70% | $135,000 | 30% | Standard: typical mid-market flip with average risk |
| 72% | $140,000 | 28% | Low-moderate risk: strong comps, simple rehab |
| 75% | $147,500 | 25% | Low risk only: cash, confirmed ARV, fast sale, peak season |
Warning: Adjusting the factor above 75% is almost never justified. At 80%, the MAO for a $250,000 ARV with $40,000 rehab is $160,000 — leaving only $50,000 for all non-purchase costs and profit. After selling costs ($21,250), carrying costs ($9,225), and financing ($2,400), the remaining profit is only $17,125 — and a single ARV miss or rehab overrun eliminates it entirely. If a deal only works at 80%, it does not work. Walk away.
Worked Example: A Complete Offer Calculation
Let us work through a complete offer calculation for a real-world scenario to demonstrate how every component fits together. The property: a 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom, 1,400 square foot single-family home in a stable mid-market neighborhood. The property is distressed — dated kitchen and baths, worn carpet, needs interior and exterior paint, roof is 25 years old, HVAC is functional but near end of life. The asking price is $160,000. We need to determine our maximum allowable offer.
Step 1 — ARV: We pull 5 sold comps within 0.5 miles, all 3BR/2BA, 1,300–1,600 sq ft, sold in the last 90 days. The comp sale prices are $245,000, $252,000, $238,000, $258,000, and $249,000. We adjust for differences: two comps have larger lots (+$3,000 each adjustment), one comp has one fewer bathroom (−$7,000 adjustment), one is on a busy street (+$5,000 adjustment). After adjustments, the adjusted values are $242,000, $249,000, $245,000, $253,000, and $249,000. The median is $249,000. We apply a 4% safety adjustment: $249,000 × 0.96 = $239,040. We round to $239,000 as our conservative ARV.
Step 2 — Rehab: We walk the property with a contractor and build an itemized scope of work: Kitchen ($12,000), Bathrooms ($7,000), Flooring ($5,000), Interior paint ($3,000), Exterior paint ($3,500), Roof ($8,000), HVAC ($6,500), Plumbing/electrical ($2,000), Permits ($1,000). Subtotal: $48,000. Add 15% contingency: $48,000 × 1.15 = $55,200. We use $55,000 as our rehab estimate. Step 3 — Costs: Purchase closing ($3,000), selling costs at 8.5% of $239,000 ($20,315), carrying costs at $1,800/month for 5 months ($9,000), financing at 2 points on a $115,000 loan ($2,300). Total non-rehab costs: $34,615. Step 4 — Profit: Target $30,000 (12.6% of ARV). Step 5 — MAO: $239,000 − $55,000 − $34,615 − $30,000 = $119,385. The asking price of $160,000 is $40,615 above our MAO — this deal does not work at the asking price. We would offer $119,000 and walk away if the seller does not accept.
| Step | Component | Amount | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ARV (conservative) | $239,000 | Median of 5 adjusted comps, less 4% safety |
| 2 | Rehab estimate | $55,000 | Itemized SOW + 15% contingency |
| 3 | Purchase closing costs | $3,000 | Title, escrow, inspection |
| 3 | Selling costs (8.5% of ARV) | $20,315 | Commission, concessions, transfer tax |
| 3 | Carrying costs (5 months) | $9,000 | $1,800/month × 5 months |
| 3 | Financing costs (2 points) | $2,300 | 2% of $115,000 hard money loan |
| 4 | Target profit margin | $30,000 | 12.6% of ARV |
| 5 | MAO (complete formula) | $119,385 | ARV − all costs − profit |
| — | 70% rule MAO (comparison) | $112,300 | ($239,000 × 0.70) − $55,000 |
| — | Asking price | $160,000 | $40,615 above MAO — deal does not work |
Hypothetical example: In this scenario, the asking price of $160,000 is $40,615 above the calculated MAO of $119,385. The investor should offer $119,000 and be prepared to walk away. If the seller counter-offers at $140,000, the deal still does not work — the MAO is a mathematical limit, not a negotiating position. The only way this deal works is if the seller accepts a price at or below the MAO, or if new information changes the inputs (e.g., a higher confirmed ARV or a lower rehab estimate). Discipline at the offer stage prevents losses at the sale stage.
Common Offer Calculation Errors
The MAO formula is simple, but the inputs are where errors creep in. The most common offer calculation errors are not in the arithmetic but in the assumptions — and each one can cause the investor to overpay by thousands of dollars. Understanding these errors before you start is the cheapest education you will ever get.
Error 1 — Overestimating ARV: Using the highest comp instead of the median, using comps from a better neighborhood, or using stale comps from 6+ months ago. Each of these inflates the ARV, which inflates the MAO, which leads to overpaying. The fix is disciplined comp selection and a 3 to 5 percent downward safety adjustment. Error 2 — Underestimating rehab: Estimating rehab from photos, using a per-square-foot rule without a scope of work, or omitting the contingency. Each of these understates the rehab cost, which inflates the MAO. The fix is an itemized scope of work with a 10 to 20 percent contingency, built before the offer.
Error 3 — Omitting carrying costs: Assuming the deal will be done in 3 months when 5 is realistic, or forgetting to include monthly interest, taxes, insurance, and utilities. This understates total costs and inflates the MAO. The fix is always including carrying costs with a conservative timeline estimate. Error 4 — Underestimating selling costs: Using 6% for commissions and forgetting concessions, transfer taxes, and home warranty. This understates selling costs and inflates the MAO. The fix is using 8.5 to 10% of ARV for total selling costs. Error 5 — No explicit profit margin: Treating profit as "whatever is left over" rather than a target. This leads to accepting deals with thin margins that cannot absorb any variance. The fix is setting an explicit profit target and walking away if the deal does not support it.
Warning: The most insidious offer calculation error is "deal fever" — wanting a particular deal so badly that you adjust the inputs to make the math work. Raising the ARV because the highest comp "proves" the property will sell for more. Lowering the rehab because "it's not that bad." Shortening the timeline because "this market is fast." Every one of these adjustments is a rationalization, not an analysis. If you have to adjust the inputs to make the deal work, the deal does not work. Trust the conservative numbers, not the optimistic ones.
Using Tools to Streamline Offer Calculation
Offer calculation is repetitive — the same formula applied to deal after deal with different inputs. Tools that automate the arithmetic allow you to evaluate more deals faster and reduce the risk of computational errors. REIVaultPro includes deal analysis tools that automate the MAO calculation, allowing you to input the ARV, rehab estimate, and cost assumptions and instantly see the maximum offer price, projected profit, and return on capital. These tools also allow you to run multiple scenarios (best case, expected case, worst case) by adjusting the inputs, so you can see how sensitive the deal is to ARV and rehab variance.
MortgageStrategist tools can help with the financing inputs — comparing hard money quotes, calculating monthly interest payments, and projecting carrying costs based on the loan amount, rate, and timeline. Having accurate financing costs is essential to a precise MAO, and a tool that compares multiple lender quotes side by side ensures you are using the best available terms rather than guessing. For investors who flip multiple properties per year, these tools pay for themselves by preventing a single bad deal that a more careful calculation would have avoided.
Regardless of the tools you use, the principle is the same: the quality of the output depends on the quality of the inputs. A tool that automates the MAO formula with sloppy ARV and rehab estimates produces a precise-looking number that is precisely wrong. Use tools to speed the arithmetic, but invest the time in getting the inputs right — walk the property, pull the comps, build the scope of work. The tool saves time; the discipline saves money.
- Use deal analysis tools to automate the MAO arithmetic and evaluate more deals faster.
- Run best-case, expected-case, and worst-case scenarios to see how sensitive the deal is to input variance.
- Use mortgage comparison tools to get accurate financing costs from multiple lender quotes.
- Never let the tool replace the discipline of walking the property and pulling real comps.
- The tool speeds the math; the quality of the inputs determines whether the number is right.
MAO and the Negotiation
The MAO is not an opening offer — it is a ceiling. Your actual offer to the seller may be below the MAO, particularly if the property has been on the market for a while or the seller is motivated. The MAO tells you the maximum you can pay while still achieving your target profit; it does not tell you what the seller will accept. The negotiation is where your maximum meets the seller's minimum, and a deal happens only if those two numbers overlap.
A common approach is to offer 5 to 10 percent below the MAO as an initial offer, leaving room to negotiate up to the MAO if the seller counter-offers. If the seller's counter is at or below the MAO, accept it. If the counter is above the MAO, counter back at the MAO or walk away. The discipline of never offering above the MAO — regardless of how much you want the deal — is what protects your profit. Investors who break this discipline and offer above the MAO to "win the deal" are transferring their profit to the seller and accepting a deal that is mathematically designed to lose money or barely break even.
In some cases, the seller's asking price is far above the MAO, and no negotiation will bridge the gap. In these cases, the right action is to move on — quickly. Time spent negotiating a deal that cannot work is time not spent finding deals that can. The most successful flippers make many offers (often 20 to 50 for every one accepted) and accept that most will be rejected. The MAO gives you the confidence to make offers without fear of overpaying, and the discipline to walk away without regret when the seller's price does not meet the math.
The MAO is your walk-away number, not your opening offer. Offer below the MAO, negotiate up to the MAO if needed, and never exceed it. The most successful flippers make dozens of offers at or below their MAO and accept that a low acceptance rate is the price of disciplined investing. One accepted deal that meets the math is worth more than ten accepted deals that do not.
Conclusion
The maximum allowable offer is the single most important number in a fix-and-flip deal, and it is the number over which the investor has the most control. The ARV is set by the market. The rehab cost is set by the property's condition. The selling and carrying costs are set by the cost of transacting and holding. But the purchase price is the investor's decision — and the 70% rule and the complete MAO formula provide the framework for making that decision with discipline. The investors who succeed at fix-and-flip are those who calculate the MAO conservatively, use accurate inputs (comparable sales for ARV, itemized scope of work for rehab, explicit estimates for all other costs), set a profit margin proportional to the deal's risk, and have the discipline to never offer above the MAO regardless of deal fever. They use the 70% rule for quick screening and the complete formula for the final offer, and they adjust the factor for deals that are riskier or safer than the typical mid-market flip. They understand that the purchase price is locked in at closing — and that every error in the offer compounds through the entire project to the sale. The framework in this guide — estimate ARV from comparable sales, build an itemized rehab estimate with a contingency, account for every closing and carrying cost, set an explicit profit margin, and calculate the MAO with the complete formula — is the foundation of an offer strategy that protects profit before capital is ever committed. Whether you are calculating your first MAO or refining your offer model for your fiftieth deal, the discipline of conservative inputs and an honest assessment of costs is what separates profitable flippers from those who learn expensive lessons about why the math matters. This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, or financial advice. Consult a licensed mortgage professional, a qualified real estate attorney, and a tax advisor for guidance specific to your situation.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the 70% rule in house flipping?
The 70% rule states that a flipper should pay no more than 70% of the after-repair value (ARV) minus the estimated rehab costs. The formula is: Maximum Allowable Offer = (ARV × 0.70) − Rehab Cost. For a property with a $250,000 ARV and $40,000 in rehab, the MAO is ($250,000 × 0.70) − $40,000 = $135,000. The 70% factor accounts for all costs other than the purchase (rehab, closing, carrying, selling) plus the investor's profit margin. The rule is a quick-screen tool — before making a final offer, run a complete deal analysis that itemizes every cost for a more precise MAO.
How do I estimate the after-repair value (ARV) accurately?
Pull 4 to 6 comparable sold properties within 0.5 miles, in the same neighborhood, with the same bedroom/bathroom count, similar square footage (within 15%), and sold within the last 90 days (180 days max in slower markets). Adjust each comp for differences (bathroom count, lot size, garage, busy street, condition), then take the median of the adjusted values. Apply a 3 to 5 percent downward safety adjustment to account for possible market softening during your hold period. Never use the highest comp as your ARV — it represents the best-case scenario, not the likely outcome. The median of adjusted comps with a safety margin is the most reliable ARV estimate.
Should I use the 70% rule or the complete MAO formula?
Use both. The 70% rule is best for quick screening — it tells you in seconds whether a deal is worth pursuing. If the asking price is above the 70% MAO, move on. The complete MAO formula (ARV − Rehab − Purchase Closing − Selling Costs − Carrying Costs − Financing − Profit) is best for the final offer because it uses specific cost estimates rather than a flat 30% assumption. The complete formula will produce a more precise MAO that reflects the actual cost structure of the deal. When the two methods produce different numbers, use the lower (more conservative) MAO to protect your margin.
What costs should I include in the MAO calculation?
Include every cost from purchase to sale: the purchase price, rehab costs (with a 10–20% contingency), purchase closing costs (1–3% of purchase price: title, escrow, inspection), carrying costs (monthly interest, taxes, insurance, utilities, maintenance × the number of months you expect to hold), selling costs (8–10% of ARV: commissions, concessions, transfer taxes), financing costs (points and fees on the loan), and your target profit margin. Omitting any of these costs inflates the MAO and leads to overpaying. The most commonly omitted costs are carrying costs and selling concessions — both of which are real and significant.
Can I adjust the 70% factor higher to win more deals?
You can, but you should do so only with great caution. Adjusting above 70% reduces your safety margin and increases the risk that a cost overrun or ARV miss will eliminate your profit. At 75%, the margin is already thin for most deals. Above 75%, the deal almost never works — the non-purchase costs and profit simply do not fit in the remaining 25%. If you find that no deals in your market work at 70%, the problem is not the factor — it is the market. Either expand to a new market, increase your deal-finding efforts to find better deals, or consider a different strategy (like BRRRR or buy-and-hold) that does not depend on buying at a steep discount.
What should I do if the seller's asking price is above my MAO?
Offer your MAO (or slightly below it) and be prepared to walk away if the seller does not accept. The MAO is a mathematical limit, not a negotiating position — if the seller's minimum is above your maximum, no deal can happen without you overpaying. Do not adjust your inputs to make the math work (raising the ARV, lowering the rehab) just to justify a higher offer. The most successful flippers make 20 to 50 offers for every one accepted, and they accept a low acceptance rate as the price of disciplined investing. Move on to the next deal — there will always be another property if you keep marketing and making offers.
Learn with Ebonie Caldwell
Keep building your investing knowledge
This guide is part of Ebonie Caldwell's real estate investing education series. Explore the contributor profile for more practical lessons, tools, and courses.
Explore Ebonie's educationReal Estate Investing Software & Education
Explore Real Estate Investment Tools
Visit REIVaultPro.com for professional services and resources.
This is a promotional link to an affiliated business of the publisher, separate from the magazine's editorial content.
Tags
Editorial Disclosure: This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute investment, tax, or legal advice. All financial examples are hypothetical illustrations and do not represent guaranteed returns. Real estate investments involve risk, including the potential loss of principal. Consult with qualified professionals before making investment decisions. Cross-marketing links to affiliated businesses are separate from editorial content.
Sources & References
- Internal Revenue Service — Publication 527, Residential Rental Property (Dealer Property and Flipping Taxation) — 2025 tax year publication (current as of 2026)
- HomeAdvisor — True Cost Guide: Home Renovation Costs by Project — Cost data updated 2026
- National Association of Home Builders (NAHB) — Remodeling Market Data and Cost Trends — Market data current as of 2026
- Attom Data Solutions — U.S. Home Flipping Report (Gross Flipping ROI and Median Flip Profits) — Most recent annual flipping report (2025–2026 data)
- U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) — FHA 203(k) Rehabilitation Mortgage Insurance Program — Program guidelines current as of 2026
Sources Last Verified: November 8, 2026

Ebonie Caldwell
Real Estate & Mortgage Strategist | Real Estate Investor & Educator
Ebonie Caldwell has 25+ years of real estate and mortgage industry experience, including real estate investing, mortgage underwriting, real estate education, financing, and investment strategies. She has provided real estate investing education to more than 14,000 students.




