Latest Headlines

Public vs. Private REITs: Liquidity, Fees, and Access

Public REITs vs. private REITs compared — exchange-traded liquidity, NAV transparency, fee structures, minimum investments, regulatory requirements, and the trade-offs of each structure

By Ebonie CaldwellReal Estate & Mortgage Strategist | Real Estate Investor & EducatorNovember 8, 202615 min read
REITs educational article illustration

When most investors think of REITs, they think of the publicly traded companies that appear on stock exchanges — names like Prologis, Equinix, Public Storage, and Simon Property Group. These are the REITs that can be bought and sold through any brokerage account, whose prices update in real time during market hours, and whose financial statements are filed with the SEC and available to anyone. But there is an entire parallel universe of REITs that never appear on an exchange: the public non-listed REITs (also called non-traded REITs) that are registered with the SEC but sold through broker-dealers and financial advisors, and the private REITs that are exempt from SEC registration entirely and offered only to accredited investors and institutions. These non-traded and private REITs have grown significantly in recent years, fueled by the search for yield, the expansion of alternative investment platforms, and the marketing reach of large sponsors. For investors, the choice between publicly traded and non-traded/private REITs is one of the most consequential decisions in REIT investing — because the two structures differ fundamentally in liquidity, transparency, fees, valuation, regulatory oversight, and the very nature of the investment experience.

The differences are not minor. A publicly traded REIT can be sold in seconds during market hours at a known price, with transaction costs of a few dollars (or zero at many brokers). A non-traded REIT may have no redemption program at all, or may allow redemptions only quarterly subject to limits and at a price determined by the sponsor (not a public market). A private REIT may offer no liquidity whatsoever — the investor's capital is locked up until the sponsor chooses to liquidate or list the REIT, which could be years or decades away. A publicly traded REIT's price is determined in real time by thousands of buyers and sellers, providing objective valuation transparency. A non-traded REIT's value is determined by periodic appraisals and reported as NAV per share, which may be infrequent, subjective, and lagging actual market conditions. A private REIT's value may be reported only annually, based on the sponsor's own valuations, with no independent verification. The fee structures also differ dramatically: publicly traded REITs have no upfront sales charges (beyond standard brokerage commissions), while non-traded REITs have historically charged upfront fees of 10%–15% of the offering price, and private REITs have a wide range of fee structures that can be difficult to evaluate.

This guide provides a comprehensive comparison of publicly traded REITs, public non-listed REITs, and private REITs across every dimension that matters to investors: liquidity, price transparency, fee structures, minimum investments, regulatory requirements and oversight, valuation methods, performance characteristics, and the trade-offs of each structure. We will cover the evolution of the non-traded REIT industry (including the shift from high-fee traditional non-traded REITs to lower-fee "NAV REITs" and "perpetual capital" structures), the regulatory framework governed by the SEC and FINRA, and the specific questions investors should ask before investing in any non-traded or private REIT. For the foundational REIT structure and the 90% distribution requirement that applies to all REITs regardless of trading venue, see our REIT investing complete guide. For the comparison of equity and mortgage REITs (which applies across public and private structures), see our equity REITs vs. mortgage REITs guide. And for the mechanics of REIT dividends and total returns, see our REIT dividends and total returns guide. Whether you are considering a non-traded REIT recommended by your financial advisor or evaluating a private REIT offered on an alternative investment platform, the framework that follows is designed to help you understand the trade-offs and make informed decisions. This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute investment, legal, or tax advice — every investment decision should be reviewed by qualified financial and tax advisors.

The Three REIT Structures: A Framework

REITs can be organized into three structural categories based on their registration status and trading venue. Publicly traded REITs are registered with the SEC under the Securities Act of 1933 and listed on a national securities exchange (NYSE, Nasdaq). They are subject to the full reporting requirements of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, including annual 10-K filings, quarterly 10-Q filings, current reports on Form 8-K, and proxy statements. Their shares trade freely on the exchange, providing daily liquidity and real-time price transparency. Any investor — retail or institutional, accredited or non-accredited — can buy or sell shares through a brokerage account during market hours. This is the most common and most accessible form of REIT investment.

Public non-listed REITs (non-traded REITs) are also registered with the SEC under the Securities Act of 1933 — meaning they file a prospectus, are subject to SEC review, and must provide ongoing reporting (10-K, 10-Q, 8-K). However, they are not listed on a national securities exchange. Their shares are sold through broker-dealers and financial advisors, typically at a fixed offering price during an "offering period" that may last several years. Because they do not trade on an exchange, there is no public market price — the shares are illiquid, and the REIT reports a NAV per share based on periodic appraisals. Redemptions (if offered) are limited and subject to the REIT's redemption program rules, which may include quarterly limits, redemption fees, and the sponsor's discretion to suspend redemptions during market stress. Non-traded REITs have evolved significantly in recent years, with newer "NAV REITs" and "perpetual capital" REITs offering more frequent NAV updates and limited monthly or quarterly liquidity compared to older "blind pool" and "lifeline" REITs that offered no liquidity until a liquidity event (listing or sale).

Private REITs (also called private placement REITs or exempt REITs) are not registered with the SEC under the Securities Act and are exempt from SEC reporting requirements. They are offered under exemptions such as Rule 506 of Regulation D or Section 4(a)(2) of the Securities Act, which means they can be sold only to accredited investors and qualified institutional buyers — not to the general public. Private REITs have no public price, no SEC filings, and no regulatory reporting requirements beyond what the sponsor voluntarily provides. Their valuations are sponsor-reported and may be infrequent or opaque. Liquidity is typically very limited or nonexistent — the investor's capital is locked up until the sponsor provides an exit (which may never come). Private REITs are used by sponsors who want to raise capital without the cost and disclosure requirements of SEC registration, and they are accessed through alternative investment platforms, registered investment advisors, and direct sponsor relationships.

FeaturePublicly Traded REITPublic Non-Listed REITPrivate REIT
SEC registrationYes (1933 Act)Yes (1933 Act)No (Reg D exempt)
Exchange listingYes (NYSE/Nasdaq)NoNo
SEC reporting (10-K, 10-Q)YesYesNo
Public market priceReal-timeNone (NAV reported)None (sponsor-reported)
Who can investAnyoneAnyone (via broker)Accredited investors only
LiquidityDaily (market hours)Limited (redemption programs)Very limited or none
Price transparencyHigh (market-determined)Moderate (periodic NAV)Low (sponsor-reported)

The three REIT structures all share the same core legal definition — they all meet the IRC Section 856 requirements (90% distribution, 75% asset test, 75% income test, 100+ shareholders, 5/50 rule). The difference is not in the REIT tax structure but in the securities regulation and trading venue. Publicly traded REITs are fully registered and exchange-listed. Non-traded REITs are registered but not exchange-listed. Private REITs are exempt from registration entirely. These differences in securities regulation create dramatically different investor experiences in terms of liquidity, transparency, fees, and oversight — even though the underlying real estate may be similar in quality.

Liquidity: The Most Important Difference

Liquidity is the single most important difference between publicly traded and non-traded/private REITs, and it should be the primary consideration for most investors. Publicly traded REITs offer daily liquidity — shares can be bought and sold on an exchange at any time during market hours, and the trade settles in two business days (T+2). This means that if you need to access your capital — for an emergency, a rebalancing decision, or a better investment opportunity — you can do so immediately at a known market price. The liquidity is provided by the exchange and the thousands of buyers and sellers who participate in the market daily. Large-cap REITs have trading volumes in the millions of shares daily, ensuring that even sizable positions can be sold without significantly moving the price.

Non-traded REITs offer limited liquidity that varies significantly by program. Traditional non-traded REITs (the older model) offered no liquidity until a "liquidity event" — typically a listing on an exchange, a sale of the REIT, or a merger — which might occur 5–10+ years after the initial offering, or might never occur at all. Investors were completely locked in. Newer "NAV REITs" and "perpetual capital" REITs (which have become the dominant non-traded REIT model since the late 2010s) offer limited redemption programs: typically, shareholders can request redemptions monthly or quarterly, subject to limits (often 2%–5% of NAV per quarter) and at the sponsor's discretion. The sponsor can suspend or limit redemptions during periods of market stress or if redemption requests exceed the available liquidity — meaning the redemption "right" is not guaranteed and may not be available when you need it most.

Private REITs generally offer the least liquidity. Many private REITs have no redemption program at all — the investor's capital is locked up until the sponsor chooses to liquidate the REIT, list it on an exchange, or provide some other exit, which may be years or decades away. Some private REITs offer limited redemption programs similar to NAV REITs, but these are at the sponsor's discretion and can be suspended. The illiquidity of private REITs is the trade-off for access to strategies or asset types that are not available in public markets — but investors must be absolutely certain they can afford to have their capital locked up for the entire holding period, with no guarantee of when (or if) they will get it back.

Liquidity FeaturePublicly TradedNon-Listed (NAV REIT)Private REIT
Trading venueNational exchangeNone (redemption program)None (sponsor discretion)
Redemption frequencyAny market dayMonthly or quarterly (if offered)Varies; often none
Redemption limitsNone2%–5% of NAV per quarter (typical)Unknown; sponsor-dependent
Suspension riskNone (market always open)Yes (sponsor can suspend)Yes (sponsor can suspend)
Price at saleMarket price (known)NAV (reported, may lag)Sponsor-determined
Time to cash2 business days (T+2)Weeks to months (if approved)Months to years (or never)
Worst-case liquidityImmediate at market priceRedemption denied; capital lockedNo exit until sponsor provides one

Warning: The liquidity of non-traded and private REITs is not guaranteed. Non-traded REIT redemption programs can be suspended or limited at the sponsor's discretion — and historically, suspensions have occurred during market stress, exactly when investors are most likely to want out. During the 2020 market crash, several non-traded REITs suspended or reduced redemptions. Private REITs may offer no redemption mechanism at all. Before investing in any non-traded or private REIT, assume your capital will be locked up for the full expected holding period (often 5–10+ years), and invest only capital you can afford to have illiquid. If you might need the money sooner, invest in publicly traded REITs instead.

Fee Structures: Upfront Fees, Ongoing Fees, and Total Cost

Fee structures differ dramatically between publicly traded and non-traded/private REITs, and the fee impact on returns can be significant. Publicly traded REITs have no upfront sales charges — you buy shares through a brokerage account and pay only the standard commission (which is $0 at many brokers for online stock trades). The REIT itself charges internal management fees and expenses (typically 0.5%–1.5% of assets annually), which are disclosed in the 10-K filing and reflected in the REIT's FFO and AFFO. There are no hidden fees, no surrender charges, and no distribution fees. The total cost of investing in a publicly traded REIT is the internal management expense ratio plus your brokerage commission (if any) — transparent, low, and easy to compare.

Traditional non-traded REITs historically charged very high upfront fees — typically 10%–15% of the offering price, deducted from the investor's capital before it was invested in real estate. This meant that if you invested $100,000, only $85,000–$90,000 actually purchased real estate, and the rest went to the sponsor, the broker-dealer, and the selling advisor as commissions and fees. This "front-load" created a significant hurdle: the real estate had to appreciate 12%–18% just for the investor to break even. These high fees were the subject of significant regulatory scrutiny from FINRA and the SEC, and they were a major reason non-traded REITs earned a poor reputation among many financial advisors and consumer advocates.

The non-traded REIT industry has evolved significantly, and newer "NAV REITs" (also called "perpetual capital REITs" or "interval funds structured as REITs") have substantially lower fee structures. Many modern NAV REITs charge upfront fees of 0%–3% (compared to 10%–15% historically), with the reduction enabled by changes in distribution models (more direct-to-investor and RIA channels rather than commission-based broker-dealer channels) and regulatory pressure. However, even NAV REITs with low upfront fees may charge ongoing fees that are higher than those of publicly traded REITs: management fees of 1%–1.5% of assets, dealer manager fees, acquisition fees, and asset management fees. The total ongoing fee load can be 2%–3%+ annually, compared to 0.5%–1.5% for publicly traded REITs. Investors must read the "Fees and Expenses" section of the prospectus carefully and calculate the total fee load (upfront + ongoing over the expected holding period) to understand the true cost.

Fee TypePublicly Traded REITTraditional Non-TradedModern NAV REITPrivate REIT
Upfront sales charge0% (brokerage commission only)10%–15% of offering price0%–3% (varies)Varies widely (0%–10%+)
Management fee (annual)0.5%–1.5% of assets1%–2% of assets1%–1.5% of assets1%–2%+ of assets
Acquisition feeIncluded in management2%–5% of acquisition price1%–3% of acquisition price1%–5% of acquisition price
Dealer manager feeNone2%–3% of offering0%–1% (or none)Varies
Surrender/redemption feeNoneUp to 5% (if redeemable)0%–2% (typical)Varies
Total first-year cost~1% (internal only)~15%–20% (upfront + ongoing)~3%–5% (upfront + ongoing)~5%–10%+ (varies)

Warning: The upfront fee on a traditional non-traded REIT (10%–15%) is a permanent drag on returns. If you invest $100,000 and $15,000 goes to fees, only $85,000 is invested in real estate. The real estate must appreciate 17.6% ($85,000 → $100,000) just for you to break even — before accounting for any ongoing fees or performance shortfalls. Modern NAV REITs with 0%–3% upfront fees are significantly better, but their ongoing fees (2%–3%+ annually) are still higher than publicly traded REITs (0.5%–1.5%). Over a 10-year holding period, a 2% annual fee difference compounds to approximately a 22% reduction in final value. Always calculate the total fee load (upfront + ongoing over the expected holding period) and compare it to the expected gross return before investing.

Valuation and Price Transparency

Price transparency is another critical difference between the three REIT structures. Publicly traded REITs provide real-time, market-determined prices — the stock price at any moment reflects the collective judgment of thousands of buyers and sellers about the value of the REIT's real estate, management, and prospects. This price may trade at a premium or discount to the REIT's estimated NAV, but it is objective, transparent, and immediately available. Investors always know exactly what their shares are worth and can track the value of their investment in real time. The market price also provides a useful feedback mechanism — if the price declines significantly, it may signal that the market sees deteriorating fundamentals, giving the investor an opportunity to reevaluate.

Non-traded REITs do not have a market price. Instead, they report a Net Asset Value (NAV) per share, which is the sponsor's estimate of the value of the REIT's real estate assets minus liabilities, divided by shares outstanding. NAV is determined through periodic appraisals — typically annually, though some NAV REITs update quarterly or monthly. The appraisal process involves independent third-party appraisers valuing each property, but the appraisals are inherently subjective (they depend on assumed cap rates, market rents, and discount rates) and backward-looking (they reflect market conditions as of the appraisal date, which may lag current conditions). The reported NAV may not reflect what the properties would actually sell for in a real transaction — and during market stress, the actual transaction values may be significantly below the reported NAV.

Private REITs provide the least price transparency. Without SEC reporting requirements, the frequency and quality of valuation reporting depends entirely on the sponsor. Some private REITs report NAV annually based on third-party appraisals, similar to non-traded REITs. Others may report only sponsor-estimated valuations with no independent appraisal. Some may provide little or no valuation information at all. The investor is essentially relying on the sponsor's word for the value of their investment, with no market price, no independent verification, and limited regulatory oversight. This makes it extremely difficult to evaluate the performance of a private REIT investment or to know whether the reported value is accurate. For investors who value transparency and the ability to monitor their investments, private REITs present significant challenges.

Valuation FeaturePublicly TradedNon-Listed (NAV REIT)Private REIT
Price sourceMarket (exchange)Periodic appraisal / NAVSponsor-reported
Update frequencyReal-time (market hours)Quarterly to annuallyAnnually (or less)
ObjectivityHigh (market-determined)Moderate (third-party appraisal)Low (sponsor-determined)
Stress-test reliabilityHigh (market prices during stress)Low (NAV may lag actual values)Very low (no independent check)
Premium/discount infoVisible (price vs. NAV estimate)N/A (NAV is the "price")N/A (no market price)
Investor ability to verifyHigh (public filings + market price)Moderate (SEC filings + NAV reports)Low (limited disclosure)

During the 2008 financial crisis and the 2020 market crash, non-traded REITs maintained their reported NAVs while publicly traded REIT prices declined 30%–50%. This led some investors to believe non-traded REITs were "less risky" — but in reality, the non-traded REIT NAVs were simply lagging actual market conditions. The appraisals had not yet caught up to the decline in real estate values. When the appraisals were eventually updated, many non-traded REITs reported significant NAV declines. The "stability" of non-traded REIT NAVs during market stress is an illusion created by infrequent valuation — it does not mean the underlying real estate is actually worth the reported value. Publicly traded REIT prices, while volatile, provide honest, real-time mark-to-market valuation.

Minimum Investments and Access

The minimum investment required to access each REIT structure varies significantly and affects who can invest. Publicly traded REITs have the lowest barrier to entry — the minimum investment is the price of one share (typically $20–$200), and any investor with a brokerage account can buy shares. This makes publicly traded REITs accessible to investors at all wealth levels, from those starting with $50 to those managing multi-million-dollar portfolios. Fractional share trading (offered by many brokers) further reduces the minimum, allowing investments as small as $1–$5 in some REITs.

Non-traded REITs typically have minimum investments of $1,000–$25,000, depending on the program. Some NAV REITs offered through online platforms have minimums as low as $1,000–$5,000, making them more accessible than traditional non-traded REITs (which often had $10,000–$25,000 minimums). The minimums are set by the sponsor and may vary by distribution channel — investments through a financial advisor may have different minimums than direct investments through the sponsor's website. Non-traded REITs are available to any investor (accredited or non-accredited) because they are SEC-registered, though some programs may be limited to accredited investors by the sponsor's choice.

Private REITs have the highest minimums and the most restrictive access. Because they are offered under Reg D exemptions, they are available only to accredited investors (individuals with $1M+ net worth excluding primary residence, or $200K+ income individually / $300K+ with spouse for two years) or qualified institutional buyers. Minimum investments are typically $25,000–$100,000+, though some institutional private REITs may have $1M+ minimums. The accredited investor requirement means that a significant portion of the investing public cannot access private REITs at all. For those who do qualify, access is typically through alternative investment platforms, registered investment advisors (RIAs), or direct relationships with the sponsor — not through standard brokerage accounts.

Access FeaturePublicly TradedNon-Listed REITPrivate REIT
Typical minimum$20–$200 (one share)$1,000–$25,000$25,000–$100,000+
Accreditation requiredNoNo (but some programs may require)Yes (Reg D requirement)
How to accessAny brokerage accountBroker-dealer, RIA, or platformAlt platforms, RIA, or direct
Fractional sharesYes (many brokers)NoNo
Available to non-accreditedYesYes (SEC-registered)No

The accessibility of publicly traded REITs is one of their most important advantages. Any investor — regardless of income, net worth, or accreditation status — can build a diversified REIT portfolio with as little as a few hundred dollars through a brokerage account and a broad REIT ETF. Non-traded REITs are also accessible to non-accredited investors (since they are SEC-registered) but require larger minimums and are typically accessed through financial advisors. Private REITs are restricted to accredited investors, limiting access to higher-net-worth individuals and institutions. If you are a non-accredited investor, your REIT options are limited to publicly traded and non-traded REITs — private REITs are not available to you.

Regulatory Oversight: SEC, FINRA, and State Regulators

The regulatory oversight of each REIT structure differs significantly, affecting the level of investor protection and the quality of disclosure available. Publicly traded REITs are subject to the most comprehensive regulatory framework. They are registered under the Securities Act of 1933 (for their initial public offering and any subsequent offerings) and are subject to the ongoing reporting requirements of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. This includes annual 10-K filings (audited financial statements, detailed property portfolios, risk factors, management discussion and analysis), quarterly 10-Q filings (unaudited financials and updates), current reports on Form 8-K (material events), and proxy statements for shareholder votes. The SEC reviews these filings, and the REIT is subject to SEC enforcement for material misstatements or omissions. The shares trade on a national exchange (NYSE or Nasdaq), which imposes additional listing standards and corporate governance requirements.

Non-traded REITs are registered under the Securities Act of 1933 and subject to the Exchange Act reporting requirements — meaning they also file 10-K, 10-Q, and 8-K reports that are available on SEC EDGAR. The SEC reviews the prospectus and ongoing filings. However, the distribution of non-traded REITs through broker-dealers adds an additional layer of regulation: the broker-dealer and its registered representatives are subject to FINRA oversight, including FINRA Rule 2111 (suitability) and FINRA Regulatory Notice 15-32 (which addresses non-traded REIT sales practices, fee disclosure, and supervision). FINRA requires broker-dealers to ensure that non-traded REIT investments are suitable for the investor, to disclose fees and conflicts of interest, and to supervise the sales practices of their representatives. State securities regulators also review non-traded REIT offerings through the North American Securities Administrators Association (NASAA) review process.

Private REITs have the least regulatory oversight. Because they are offered under Reg D exemptions, they are not registered with the SEC and are not subject to Exchange Act reporting requirements. They file a Form D with the SEC (a brief notice of the exempt offering) but do not file 10-K, 10-Q, or 8-K reports. There is no SEC review of the offering materials, no ongoing SEC disclosure requirements, and no exchange oversight. The investor's protection comes from: (1) the accreditation requirement (which assumes accredited investors can fend for themselves), (2) the anti-fraud provisions of federal and state securities laws (which apply regardless of registration status), and (3) any contractual protections in the REIT's operating agreement. If the sponsor provides inaccurate information or mismanages the REIT, the investor's primary recourse is a private lawsuit — there is no regulatory body actively monitoring the investment.

Regulatory FeaturePublicly TradedNon-Listed REITPrivate REIT
SEC registration (1933 Act)YesYesNo (Reg D exempt)
SEC reporting (10-K, 10-Q, 8-K)YesYesNo
Exchange listing standardsYes (NYSE/Nasdaq)NoNo
FINRA broker-dealer oversightN/A (exchange-traded)Yes (for distribution)Limited (if sold via BD)
State regulator reviewYesYes (NASAA review)Limited (Form D notice only)
SEC EDGAR filings availableYesYesForm D only
Investor disclosure qualityHigh (full SEC reporting)High (full SEC reporting)Low (sponsor discretion)

Warning: The reduced regulatory oversight of private REITs means investors must conduct their own due diligence with less information and fewer protections. There are no SEC-filed financial statements, no independent audit requirements (unless contractually required), and no exchange listing standards. The investor relies entirely on the sponsor's voluntary disclosures, which may be infrequent, incomplete, or self-serving. If the sponsor misrepresents the REIT's performance or valuation, the investor may not discover the problem until significant losses have occurred. The anti-fraud provisions of securities laws provide a legal remedy, but litigation is expensive, time-consuming, and uncertain. Always conduct thorough due diligence on the sponsor's track record, reputation, and alignment before investing in any private REIT.

The Evolution of Non-Traded REITs: From High Fees to NAV REITs

The non-traded REIT industry has undergone a significant transformation over the past decade, driven by regulatory pressure, competitive forces, and changing investor expectations. Understanding this evolution is important because the reputation of non-traded REITs was shaped by the older, high-fee model — but the current industry is meaningfully different, with both improvements and ongoing concerns.

The first generation of non-traded REITs (dominant from the 1990s through the early 2010s) were characterized by high upfront fees (10%–15%), no liquidity until a liquidity event (which might never come), infrequent NAV updates (annually or less), and a "blind pool" structure where investors committed capital before knowing exactly which properties the REIT would buy. These REITs were sold primarily through commission-based broker-dealers, and the high upfront fees created conflicts of interest (the broker earned a large commission for selling the REIT, regardless of whether it was suitable for the investor). FINRA and the SEC increased scrutiny of these practices, and several enforcement actions highlighted cases where non-traded REITs were sold unsuitably to investors who could not afford the illiquidity.

The second generation — "NAV REITs" or "perpetual capital REITs" — emerged in the late 2010s and have become the dominant non-traded REIT model. These REITs feature: significantly lower upfront fees (0%–3% in many cases, enabled by direct-to-investor and RIA distribution channels rather than commission-based broker-dealer channels); more frequent NAV updates (monthly or quarterly rather than annually); limited monthly or quarterly redemption programs (typically 2%–5% of NAV per quarter, subject to limits and sponsor discretion); and continuous offerings (investors can buy in at any time at the current NAV, rather than during a fixed offering period at a fixed price). Companies like Blackstone (BREIT), Starwood (SREIT), and Brookfield (BRE) have raised tens of billions of dollars through these NAV REIT structures, making them some of the largest real estate vehicles in the world. The improvements are real — lower fees, more frequent valuations, and some liquidity — but the fundamental trade-offs (limited and discretionary liquidity, appraisal-based valuation, and higher ongoing fees than public REITs) remain.

FeatureTraditional Non-Traded (Gen 1)NAV REIT (Gen 2)Publicly Traded
Upfront fee10%–15%0%–3%0%
NAV update frequencyAnnual or lessMonthly to quarterlyReal-time (market price)
LiquidityNone until liquidity eventMonthly/quarterly (limited, discretionary)Daily (market hours)
Offering structureFixed offering periodContinuous offering at NAVExchange-traded
Distribution channelCommission-based broker-dealerRIA, direct, platformBrokerage account
Ongoing fees1.5%–2.5% annually1.5%–3% annually0.5%–1.5% annually

The evolution from traditional non-traded REITs to modern NAV REITs represents real improvement — lower upfront fees, more frequent valuations, and some liquidity. However, investors should not assume that a modern NAV REIT is equivalent to a publicly traded REIT. The ongoing fees are still higher (1.5%–3% vs. 0.5%–1.5%), the liquidity is still limited and discretionary (vs. daily and guaranteed), and the valuation is still appraisal-based (vs. market-determined). The improvements reduce but do not eliminate the structural disadvantages of non-traded REITs relative to publicly traded REITs. Evaluate each NAV REIT on its specific terms — fee structure, redemption program limits, valuation methodology, and sponsor quality — rather than assuming all NAV REITs are the same.

Performance Comparison: Returns, Volatility, and Correlation

Comparing the historical performance of publicly traded and non-traded/private REITs is challenging because the non-traded REIT market is smaller, more diverse, and has less consistent data. However, several observations can be made based on available data and academic research. On a gross return basis (before fees), non-traded REITs own real estate that is broadly similar in quality to publicly traded REIT real estate — so the underlying real estate returns should be comparable. The differences in investor returns come primarily from fees, liquidity, and the "return gap" created by appraisal-based vs. market-based valuation.

The fee impact is the most measurable difference. A non-traded REIT with a 10% upfront fee and 2% annual ongoing fees (traditional model) must earn 12%+ on its real estate in the first year just for the investor to break even — compared to a publicly traded REIT where the full investment goes to work immediately and ongoing fees are 1% or less. Over a 10-year holding period, the cumulative fee drag of a traditional non-traded REIT can be 20%–30% of the initial investment, meaning the non-traded REIT must generate 20%–30% more gross return than the public REIT just to match the investor's net return. Modern NAV REITs with 0%–3% upfront fees have a smaller fee disadvantage (perhaps 5%–15% cumulative over 10 years), but the gap is still meaningful.

The "volatility illusion" of non-traded REITs is another important consideration. Because non-traded REIT NAVs are based on infrequent appraisals rather than daily market prices, their reported returns appear much less volatile than publicly traded REIT returns. Some studies have shown that non-traded REITs report annualized volatility of 3%–5%, compared to 15%–25% for publicly traded REITs. However, this lower volatility is an artifact of the valuation method — the underlying real estate is just as volatile, but the infrequent appraisals smooth out the price movements. Academic research (including studies by the MIT Center for Real Estate and others) has attempted to "unsmooth" non-traded REIT returns and found that the true volatility is much closer to publicly traded REITs than the reported figures suggest. The lower reported volatility may feel comforting, but it does not mean the investment is actually less risky — it means the risk is hidden by the valuation method.

Performance DimensionPublicly TradedNon-Listed (NAV REIT)Private REIT
Gross real estate returnComparable (similar assets)Comparable (similar assets)Comparable (varies by strategy)
Fee drag (10-year cumulative)~5%–10%~15%–25% (NAV); ~30%+ (traditional)~15%–30%+ (varies)
Reported volatility15%–25% (market-based)3%–8% (appraisal-smoothed)3%–8% (if reported)
"Unsmoothed" volatility15%–25%~12%–20% (estimated)Unknown (limited data)
Correlation with stocks0.4–0.6 (moderate)0.1–0.3 (low, partly due to smoothing)0.0–0.2 (very low, if reported)
Liquidity premium/discountNone (liquid)Discount expected (illiquid)Large discount expected (very illiquid)

The low correlation of non-traded and private REITs with public markets is often cited as a diversification benefit — and it is real, but partly for the wrong reason. The low correlation comes partly from the infrequent, appraisal-based valuation (which does not move with daily market sentiment) rather than from genuinely different return drivers. If the non-traded REIT's real estate were marked to market daily, the correlation with publicly traded REITs would be much higher (because they own similar real estate). The diversification benefit is real in the sense that non-traded REIT returns are not affected by daily market sentiment — but investors should not assume the underlying real estate risk is fundamentally different from public REIT risk. The "diversification" is partly a valuation-method artifact, not a genuine difference in asset risk.

When Non-Traded or Private REITs Might Make Sense

Despite their structural disadvantages (higher fees, limited liquidity, less transparency), non-traded and private REITs can make sense for certain investors in certain situations. The key is understanding the specific benefits they offer and whether those benefits justify the trade-offs for your specific situation. Non-traded and private REITs are not inherently bad investments — they are investments with specific characteristics that may or may not fit an investor's objectives.

Non-traded REITs may make sense for investors who: (1) want real estate exposure with lower reported volatility than publicly traded REITs (accepting that the lower volatility is partly an artifact of appraisal-based valuation); (2) want access to specific property types or strategies that are not well-represented in the public REIT market (e.g., certain niche sectors, middle-market assets, or specific geographic concentrations); (3) have a long time horizon and do not need liquidity (and are compensated for the illiquidity through potentially higher gross returns); or (4) are working with a financial advisor who recommends a specific non-traded REIT as part of a comprehensive portfolio plan. The large NAV REITs (Blackstone BREIT, Starwood SREIT, etc.) offer access to institutional-quality real estate and professional management that may be attractive to certain investors, and their lower-fee structure (compared to traditional non-traded REITs) makes them more competitive than older non-traded REIT products.

Private REITs may make sense for accredited investors who: (1) want access to specialized strategies not available in public markets (e.g., focused sector strategies, development-oriented REITs, or niche property types); (2) are comfortable with the lack of transparency and regulatory oversight in exchange for potentially higher returns; (3) have a very long time horizon and no liquidity needs; and (4) have a strong relationship with and confidence in the sponsor's track record and alignment. Private REITs are generally most appropriate for sophisticated investors who can conduct thorough due diligence, understand the risks, and have the financial capacity to absorb a total loss if the investment goes wrong. They are generally not appropriate for investors who need liquidity, transparency, or regulatory protection.

Investor SituationRecommended Structure
Need daily liquidityPublicly traded REITs only
Want low fees and transparencyPublicly traded REITs
Want lower reported volatility (accept appraisal smoothing)Non-traded NAV REIT (lower-fee)
Want access to niche strategy not in public marketNon-traded or private REIT (if due diligence supports)
Accredited, long horizon, no liquidity needsNon-traded or private REIT may be appropriate
Non-accredited investorPublicly traded or non-traded REIT (not private)
Uncomfortable with limited transparencyPublicly traded REITs only
Working with advisor who recommends non-traded REITEvaluate carefully; compare to public REIT alternative

Before investing in any non-traded or private REIT, ask yourself: "Could I achieve similar or better results with publicly traded REITs at lower cost and with daily liquidity?" If the answer is yes, the non-traded/private REIT is hard to justify. If the non-traded/private REIT offers a genuinely different strategy, property type, or return profile that you cannot replicate in the public market, and you are comfortable with the liquidity and transparency trade-offs, it may be worth considering. Always compare the total fee load (upfront + ongoing) to the expected return, and always read the prospectus or offering memorandum carefully. For tools to track your total real estate portfolio — including public REITs, non-traded REITs, and direct investments — consider REIVaultPro, which provides consolidated portfolio tracking and analysis. If you are also managing mortgage strategies on direct real estate holdings, MortgageStrategist provides complementary tools for optimizing your financing.

Due Diligence Questions for Non-Traded and Private REITs

Investors considering a non-traded or private REIT should conduct more thorough due diligence than for a publicly traded REIT, because the reduced regulatory oversight and transparency mean the investor bears more responsibility for evaluating the investment. The following questions should be answered before committing capital to any non-traded or private REIT.

Questions about fees and costs: What is the total upfront fee (as a percentage of the offering price)? What are the ongoing annual fees (management, acquisition, asset management, dealer manager)? Is there a surrender or redemption fee? What is the total fee load over the expected holding period (upfront + ongoing)? How does this compare to publicly traded REIT alternatives? Are there any performance fees or promote structures? How are conflicts of interest disclosed and managed? Questions about liquidity: What is the redemption program (if any)? What are the limits (quarterly cap, per-investor cap)? Has the redemption program ever been suspended or limited? What is the historical redemption approval rate? What happens if redemption requests exceed the available liquidity? What is the expected holding period before a liquidity event?

Questions about valuation and performance: How is NAV determined? How frequently is NAV updated? Are appraisals conducted by independent third parties? What is the historical NAV per share trend (growth, decline, or flat)? How do the reported returns compare to publicly traded REIT benchmarks? Has the REIT ever written down its NAV? What are the underlying real estate fundamentals (occupancy, NOI growth, cap rates)? Questions about the sponsor: What is the sponsor's track record (on this REIT and on prior vehicles)? Has the sponsor ever had a failed or underperforming REIT? Are there any regulatory actions or investor complaints against the sponsor? How much of the sponsor's own capital is invested alongside investors? What is the sponsor's reputation in the industry? For private REITs, in particular, the due diligence burden is high because there are no SEC filings to rely on — the investor must obtain all information directly from the sponsor and verify it independently where possible.

  • Fees: What is the total upfront fee? What are ongoing annual fees? What is the total fee load over the expected holding period?
  • Liquidity: What is the redemption program? What are the limits? Has it ever been suspended?
  • Valuation: How is NAV determined? How frequently? By independent appraisers? What is the NAV trend?
  • Performance: How do reported returns compare to public REIT benchmarks? Has NAV ever been written down?
  • Sponsor: What is the track record? Any prior failures or regulatory actions? How much sponsor co-investment?
  • Alternative: Could I achieve similar exposure with publicly traded REITs at lower cost and with daily liquidity?
  • Read the full prospectus or offering memorandum before investing — do not rely solely on marketing materials.
  • For private REITs, conduct enhanced due diligence due to the absence of SEC filings and regulatory oversight.

Making the Choice: A Decision Framework

The choice between publicly traded, non-traded, and private REITs should be driven by the investor's specific objectives, constraints, and preferences — not by what a financial advisor recommends or what an investment platform promotes. The decision framework below synthesizes the key considerations from this guide into a practical evaluation process.

Step 1 — Assess your liquidity needs. If you need daily liquidity (you might need to access the capital within the investment horizon, or you want the flexibility to rebalance or respond to opportunities), publicly traded REITs are the only appropriate choice. If you can commit capital for 5–10+ years with limited or no liquidity, non-traded or private REITs become feasible. Be honest about your liquidity needs — many investors underestimate the probability that they will need access to their capital before the expected holding period ends. Step 2 — Evaluate your fee sensitivity. If minimizing fees is a priority (and it should be for most investors), publicly traded REITs have a structural advantage. The cumulative fee drag of non-traded and private REITs (even modern NAV REITs) can reduce returns by 5%–25%+ over a 10-year period relative to public REITs with similar underlying real estate.

Step 3 — Consider transparency and oversight. If you value the ability to monitor your investment in real time, access SEC-filed financial statements, and rely on regulatory oversight, publicly traded REITs are superior. If you are comfortable relying on sponsor-reported information and conducting your own due diligence, non-traded or private REITs may be acceptable. Step 4 — Assess the specific investment opportunity. Does the non-traded or private REIT offer something you cannot get in the public market — a specific property type, strategy, or return profile? If yes, and the fees, liquidity, and transparency trade-offs are acceptable, it may be worth considering. If no, and you could achieve similar exposure with publicly traded REITs, the non-traded/private REIT is hard to justify. Step 5 — Verify accreditation (for private REITs). If you are not an accredited investor, private REITs are not available to you — the choice is between publicly traded and non-traded REITs. For most investors, the default choice should be publicly traded REITs (through a broad REIT ETF or a diversified selection of individual REITs), with non-traded or private REITs considered only when there is a compelling, specific reason that justifies the structural trade-offs. For a broader discussion of real estate portfolio construction, see our real estate diversification guide.

Decision FactorPublicly TradedNon-Listed REITPrivate REIT
Daily liquidity needed✓ Recommended✗ Insufficient✗ No liquidity
Minimize fees✓ Lowest fees△ Higher fees✗ Highest fees (varies)
Transparency priority✓ Full SEC reporting✓ Full SEC reporting✗ Limited disclosure
Regulatory oversight✓ Full oversight✓ Full oversight△ Limited oversight
Access to niche strategy△ Limited to public market✓ May offer niche access✓ May offer niche access
Accredited investors only— (open to all)— (open to all)✓ Required
Lower reported volatility✗ Market volatility✓ Appraisal-smoothed✓ Appraisal-smoothed (if reported)

For the majority of investors, publicly traded REITs are the best default choice. They offer daily liquidity, the lowest fees, the highest transparency, full regulatory oversight, and access to a broad range of property types and sectors. Non-traded and private REITs should be considered only when there is a specific, compelling reason — such as access to a strategy not available in the public market — and only after thorough due diligence on fees, liquidity, valuation, and sponsor quality. Never invest in a non-traded or private REIT solely because a financial advisor recommended it or because the yield looks attractive — always compare it to the publicly traded REIT alternative and make an informed choice.

Conclusion

The choice between publicly traded, non-traded, and private REITs is one of the most consequential decisions in REIT investing, because the three structures differ fundamentally in liquidity, fees, transparency, valuation, and regulatory oversight — even though they may hold similar underlying real estate. Publicly traded REITs offer daily liquidity, real-time market pricing, the lowest fees, full SEC reporting, and comprehensive regulatory oversight. They are accessible to all investors at a minimum investment as low as the price of one share. For most investors, publicly traded REITs (through a broad ETF or a diversified selection of individual REITs) should be the default choice for REIT exposure.

Non-traded REITs and private REITs offer different trade-offs. Modern NAV REITs have improved significantly from the older, high-fee non-traded REIT model — with lower upfront fees (0%–3% vs. 10%–15%), more frequent NAV updates, and limited redemption programs — but they still carry higher ongoing fees, limited and discretionary liquidity, appraisal-based valuation, and less price transparency than publicly traded REITs. Private REITs add further restrictions: accredited-investor-only access, no SEC reporting, sponsor-reported valuations, and often no liquidity mechanism at all. These structures may make sense for specific investors with specific objectives — access to niche strategies, tolerance for illiquidity, comfort with limited transparency — but they should be evaluated carefully against the publicly traded alternative, with full attention to the total fee load, the redemption program terms, and the sponsor's track record.

Whether you are investing in your first REIT or evaluating a non-traded REIT recommended by your advisor, the framework in this guide is designed to help you make an informed choice. For the foundational REIT structure and key metrics, see our REIT investing complete guide. For the comparison of equity and mortgage REITs (which applies across all structures), see our equity REITs vs. mortgage REITs guide. For the mechanics of REIT dividends and total returns, see our REIT dividends and total returns guide. And for the decision between REITs and direct property ownership, see our REITs vs. direct real estate ownership guide. For the broader context of pooled real estate investment, see our real estate syndication complete guide and private equity real estate fund guide. This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute investment, legal, or tax advice. Every investment decision should be reviewed by qualified financial and tax advisors.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between a publicly traded REIT and a non-traded REIT?

A publicly traded REIT is listed on a national securities exchange (NYSE or Nasdaq) and its shares can be bought and sold by any investor through a brokerage account during market hours. It has a real-time, market-determined price and daily liquidity. A non-traded REIT (also called a public non-listed REIT) is registered with the SEC but is not listed on an exchange. Its shares are sold through broker-dealers or platforms at a sponsor-determined offering price, and there is no public market price. Liquidity is limited — non-traded REITs may offer quarterly redemption programs (typically limited to 2%–5% of NAV per quarter, subject to sponsor discretion) or no liquidity at all until a liquidity event. Both are SEC-registered and file 10-K, 10-Q, and 8-K reports, but the investor experience is fundamentally different in terms of liquidity, price transparency, and fees.

Are non-traded REITs riskier than publicly traded REITs?

Non-traded REITs carry different risks than publicly traded REITs, and in several dimensions they are riskier. The primary additional risks are: (1) Liquidity risk — you may not be able to access your capital when you need it, as redemption programs can be suspended or limited during market stress. (2) Fee risk — non-traded REITs historically charged 10%–15% upfront fees (modern NAV REITs charge 0%–3%), plus higher ongoing fees (1.5%–3% vs. 0.5%–1.5% for public REITs), creating a significant return drag. (3) Valuation risk — NAV is based on infrequent appraisals that may lag actual market conditions, meaning the reported value may not reflect what the properties would actually sell for. The underlying real estate risk is similar, but the structural risks (liquidity, fees, valuation transparency) are higher. The lower reported volatility of non-traded REITs is partly an artifact of appraisal-based valuation, not a sign of genuinely lower risk.

What is a NAV REIT and how is it different from a traditional non-traded REIT?

A NAV REIT (also called a "perpetual capital REIT") is the modern evolution of the non-traded REIT structure. Key differences from traditional non-traded REITs: (1) Lower upfront fees — NAV REITs typically charge 0%–3% vs. 10%–15% for traditional non-traded REITs. (2) More frequent NAV updates — monthly or quarterly vs. annually or less. (3) Limited redemption programs — monthly or quarterly redemptions (typically 2%–5% of NAV per quarter) vs. no liquidity until a liquidity event. (4) Continuous offering — investors can buy in at any time at the current NAV vs. a fixed offering period at a fixed price. (5) Distribution through RIAs and direct channels vs. commission-based broker-dealers. Large NAV REITs include Blackstone BREIT, Starwood SREIT, and Brookfield REIT. The improvements are real, but the fundamental trade-offs (limited and discretionary liquidity, appraisal-based valuation, higher ongoing fees than public REITs) remain.

Who can invest in a private REIT?

Private REITs are offered under SEC exemptions (typically Regulation D, Rule 506) and are available only to accredited investors and qualified institutional buyers. An accredited individual is one who has either (1) net worth over $1,000,000 (excluding primary residence), individually or with spouse, OR (2) income over $200,000 individually ($300,000 with spouse) in each of the last two years with a reasonable expectation of the same in the current year. Entities (trusts, LLCs, partnerships) can also qualify as accredited under specific criteria. Non-accredited investors cannot invest in private REITs. Minimum investments are typically $25,000–$100,000+. Private REITs have no SEC registration, no SEC reporting requirements (beyond a Form D notice), and no public market price — investors rely entirely on sponsor-provided information. This makes thorough due diligence on the sponsor's track record, reputation, and alignment especially important.

Why do non-traded REITs charge higher fees than publicly traded REITs?

Non-traded REITs charge higher fees for several reasons: (1) Distribution costs — non-traded REITs are sold through broker-dealers and financial advisors who earn commissions, which are paid from the offering proceeds (traditional non-traded REITs: 10%–15% upfront; NAV REITs: lower but still include dealer manager fees). Publicly traded REITs are bought directly through brokerage accounts with no sales charge. (2) Ongoing management and administration — non-traded REITs typically charge 1.5%–3% annually in management, acquisition, and asset management fees, compared to 0.5%–1.5% for public REITs. (3) Smaller scale and higher per-unit costs — non-traded REITs may have higher per-unit operating costs due to smaller scale and less efficient capital structures. (4) Lack of competitive pressure — publicly traded REITs compete on price in an efficient market, while non-traded REITs are sold (not bought), reducing fee competition. The fee difference can reduce investor returns by 5%–25%+ over a 10-year holding period relative to comparable public REITs.

Should I invest in a non-traded REIT recommended by my financial advisor?

Evaluate any non-traded REIT recommendation carefully, and do not invest solely because your advisor recommended it. Key questions: (1) Is the advisor earning a commission for selling this REIT? (If yes, there is a conflict of interest — the advisor benefits financially from your purchase.) (2) What is the total fee load (upfront + ongoing) and how does it compare to publicly traded REIT alternatives? (3) What is the redemption program, and has it ever been suspended? (4) Could I achieve similar real estate exposure with publicly traded REITs at lower cost and with daily liquidity? If the answer to the last question is yes, the non-traded REIT is hard to justify unless it offers a specific strategy or property type you cannot access in the public market. Ask your advisor to explain specifically why this non-traded REIT is better than a public REIT alternative, and consider getting a second opinion from a fee-only (non-commissioned) advisor. Always read the prospectus before investing.

Learn with Ebonie Caldwell

Keep building your investing knowledge

This guide is part of Ebonie Caldwell's real estate investing education series. Explore the contributor profile for more practical lessons, tools, and courses.

Explore Ebonie's education

Real Estate Investing Software & Education

Explore Real Estate Investment Tools

Visit REIVaultPro.com for professional services and resources.

Visit Site

This is a promotional link to an affiliated business of the publisher, separate from the magazine's editorial content.

Editorial Disclosure: This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute investment, tax, or legal advice. All financial examples are hypothetical illustrations and do not represent guaranteed returns. Real estate investments involve risk, including the potential loss of principal. Consult with qualified professionals before making investment decisions. Cross-marketing links to affiliated businesses are separate from editorial content.

Ebonie Caldwell

Ebonie Caldwell

Real Estate & Mortgage Strategist | Real Estate Investor & Educator

Ebonie Caldwell has 25+ years of real estate and mortgage industry experience, including real estate investing, mortgage underwriting, real estate education, financing, and investment strategies. She has provided real estate investing education to more than 14,000 students.

More in REITs

Affiliated resource

REI Invest Capital — Property Selling & Investment Resources

Explore off-market real estate, property selling options, investor financing information, and real estate partnership opportunities.

Visit REI Invest Capital

REI Invest Capital is an affiliated business resource of the publisher. Availability, terms, and outcomes are not guaranteed. Review information independently before making a property or financing decision.